loader image

No Religious Angle in Reassignment of Cases: CJI Surya Kant May Reassign More Cases To Ensure Compliance With Supreme Court Roster

No Religious Angle in Reassignment of Cases: CJI Surya Kant May Reassign More Cases To Ensure Compliance With Supreme Court Roster

Chief Justice of India Justice Surya Kant is considering further case reassignments amid concerns over judicial proceedings being expanded from individual grievances into nationwide inquiries beyond the subject-wise allocation under the Supreme Court roster. The move follows the transfer of two high-profile matters from Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah’s Bench: the nationwide examination of private universities to a Bench headed by Justice Vikram Nath, and the proceedings concerning unauthorised constructions and commercial use of residential properties to a Bench led by Justice BV Nagarathna.

Separately, the CJI has ruled out any religious consideration behind the administrative decisions, following questions raised in connection with a distinct stray-animal case. Concerns had been raised over the implications of the Court’s directions for cows and their religious significance. The CJI has made clear that these concerns had no bearing on the administrative decisions to reassign cases to different benches.

The clarification comes amid discussion over the reassignment of two significant proceedings earlier heard by a Bench led by Justice Amanullah. These include the case concerning the regulation and functioning of private universities across the country, which has now been assigned to a three-judge Bench headed by Justice Vikram Nath, and the proceedings concerning unauthorised constructions and commercial use of residential properties, which have been transferred to a Bench led by Justice B.V. Nagarathna.

Both matters had initially originated from individual grievances but subsequently expanded into nationwide exercises involving multiple States, government authorities and regulatory bodies.

Also Read: Supreme Court Reassigns Two Part-Heard Cases From Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah’s Bench

The reassignment had triggered questions about the circumstances behind the administrative decision. The latest clarification indicates that the issue under consideration is the allocation of judicial business in accordance with the roster, rather than the religious identity of any party or the subject matter of the cases.

It is confirmed that in a recent full Court meeting, the CJI emphasised that judges must hear matters in accordance with the subjects assigned to them under the roster. Notably, the Chief Justice, as the Master of the Roster, is responsible for allocating judicial business among different Benches.

Also Read: After Reassignment Of Part-Heard Cases From Justice Amanullah’s Bench, Justice PV Sanjay Kumar Refers Suo Motu Central Secretariat Library Case To CJI