Professor (Dr.) Faizan Mustafa, Vice-Chancellor of Chanakya National Law University, Patna, on November 18 spoke at a lecture titled “Jurisprudence of the Common Good: Fraternity and the Right to Human Flourishing” as part of the Supreme Court of India’s Monthly Lecture and Dialogue Series, where he emphasised that fraternity requires an inclusive sense of national belonging, with no one’s identity or belonging to India being questioned. Referring to Dr. B.R. Ambedkar’s assertion that “we are Indians firstly and lastly”, he said that a person’s right to live with dignity and become fully human should not be constrained by caste or creed. He also referred Sonia Gandhi’s memoir, Belonging: A Journey of Love, which had been making headlines over the preceding week, to underline that fraternity demands that people belong to one another and that no one’s belonging to India should be suspected.
He stated that fraternity is not merely an expression of goodwill between citizens but a constitutional commitment that requires people to live together as equals despite their differences. Referring to Dr. B.R. Ambedkar’s understanding of fraternity, Faizan Mustafa said that it was the principle that gave unity and solidarity to social life. He observed that while liberty and equality have received considerable attention in constitutional discourse, fraternity has often remained neglected.
He said that fraternity must be understood as a social arrangement that allows people to cross barriers of caste, religion and community, rather than merely as a sentiment. Referring to Ambedkar’s concept of social endosmosis, he explained that a fraternal society is one in which people freely interact across social groups, including through shared spaces, education, work and marriage.
He also cautioned against invoking fraternity to justify majoritarian or authoritarian projects. Drawing upon the work of Professor Farrah Ahmed, he discussed how the idea could be distorted through hierarchy, restrictions on liberty, assumptions of majority-community generosity and the exclusion or objectification of women.
“
“Constitutional Courts cannot be that constable forever, and it should not want to be. What it can do is protect the conditions under which fraternity grows on its own: the freedom to move about and mix with our fellow citizens, to marry across the lines our grandparents drew, to speak and worship without fear, to draw water from the same well and rent a room in the same building. Today, their citizenship and right to vote too need protection,” he said.
Referring to the Supreme Court’s decision in Francis Coralie Mullin v. Administrator, Union Territory of Delhi, he highlighted the interpretation of Article 21, under which the right to life extends beyond mere survival to include the right to live with human dignity. He drew attention to the Court’s observation that human dignity includes the freedom to move about and interact with fellow human beings.
He also contrasted the Supreme Court’s approaches in Subramanian Swamy v. Union of India and Shaheen Abdulla v. Union of India. He observed that while the former treated fraternity as a responsibility of the individual towards society, the latter placed an obligation on the State to ensure that members of different religious and caste communities could live in harmony.
Faizan Mustafa emphasised that the latter approach was more consistent with the Preamble’s promise of fraternity assuring the dignity of the individual. He said that fraternity should operate as a constitutional safeguard against the State privileging or subordinating any group of citizens.
He further referred to the Supreme Court’s jurisprudence on the common good, including Nandini Sundar v. State of Chhattisgarh, (2011) 7 SCC 547, and the nine-judge Bench decision in Property Owners Association v. State of Maharashtra, 2024 INSC 835. He discussed how the common good should not be confined to a particular economic ideology or imposed as the will of the majority.
Concluding his address, Faizan Mustafa said that the common good, fraternity and human flourishing were interconnected constitutional aspirations. He stressed that the right to human flourishing meant being able to live in a society where a person’s caste or religious identity did not become an obstacle to living with dignity.
“
“The common good, fraternity and flourishing are three names for one hope: that the admi may become insan, and that none of us has to travel that distance alone,” he concluded.

