loader image

Allahabad High Court Bars Hookah Service in UP Restaurants Even in Designated Smoking Areas

Allahabad High Court Bars Hookah Service in UP Restaurants Even in Designated Smoking Areas

M/s Aftek Foods and Beverages Pvt. Ltd. vs State of U.P. & connected matters [Order dated September 29, 2026]

Hookah Service Ban in Restaurants

The Allahabad High Court has held that restaurants and similar establishments in Uttar Pradesh cannot provide hookah services, including within a designated smoking area. A Division Bench of Justice Shekhar B. Saraf and Justice Abhdesh Kumar Chaudhary dismissed a batch of connected petitions concerning the operation of hookah bars and provision of hookah services in restaurants.

The Court delivered the judgment in a batch of petitions filed by restaurants and establishments seeking permission to provide hookah facilities to patrons in designated smoking areas.

The petitions arose from a dispute over the interpretation of Rule 4(3) of the Prohibition of Smoking in Public Places Rules, 2008, as amended in 2017. The establishments argued that hookah could be provided through a self-service model without violating the prohibition on rendering services inside a designated smoking area.

The Court, however, held that the amended provision creates an absolute prohibition on services within such areas. The Bench observed:

“

“The 2017 amendment to Rule 4(3) imposes an absolute and unqualified prohibition on all services within a Designated Smoking Area. The prohibition so enacted admits no exception to service of any nature or description whatsoever and includes service of food, beverages, tobacco products, herbal products and hookah.”

The Court rejected the petitioners’ contention that they could avoid the prohibition by preparing the hookah outside the designated smoking area and allowing customers to operate it themselves.

The Bench noted that the operation of a hookah involves several stages and cannot simply be characterised as an activity independently undertaken by the customer. It held:

“

“These elements such as preparing, assembling, delivering, lighting, replenishing, and maintaining a hookah for its patron for a consideration leads one to the inescapable finding that providing hookah in a restaurant amounts to ‘service’ as per the amended Rule 4(3).”

The Court also rejected the argument that providing a prepared hookah amounted to merely renting the apparatus. It distinguished the arrangement from ordinary equipment rental, observing that the customer is required to use the hookah within the designated smoking area of the establishment. The Bench held that the 2017 amendment had also altered the legal position considered earlier by the Supreme Court in Narinder S. Chadha v. Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai, which dealt with the earlier wording of Rule 4(3).

The High Court also rejected the argument that restaurants could circumvent the prohibition by adopting a self-service model, under which the establishment would prepare the hookah but the customer would operate it. It held that the procedural operation of a hookah intrinsically involves service and requires expertise. It observed:

“

“The self-service model hypothetically synthesised by the petitioners to skirt around the clutches of the COTPA and the amended Rules is not a viable model as procedural operation of hookah intrinsically involves ‘service’ which needs to be carried out by the one having expertise in it and is not an operation that can be carried out by patrons who are not trained and are novices.”

The Court held that the designated smoking area under the proviso to Section 4 of the Cigarettes and Other Tobacco Products Act, 2003 (COTPA) is an exception to the general prohibition on smoking in public places and must therefore be interpreted narrowly. The Bench said:

“

“The Designated Smoking Area as provided in proviso to Section 4, being an exception to the general rule of prohibition of smoking in public places must be read strictly, narrowly, and in a manner that advances rather than undermines the dominant prohibitory philosophy and overarching public health objective of the COTPA.”

The Court further held that the State’s power to regulate an activity under COTPA includes the power to prohibit it altogether where required by the statutory framework.

The Court further examined the relationship between the commercial rights of restaurants and the rights of non-smokers. It held that the right to carry on a trade under Article 19(1)(g) cannot override the right of non-smokers to breathe clean air under Article 21. The judgment stated:

“

“The right of the non-smoker to breathe clean air in a public place is a fundamental right guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution of India, that cannot be abridged by commercial interest of an establishment having Right to Trade under Article 19(1)(g) of the Constitution of India. This Court holds, accordingly, that the operation of hookah bars and the rendering of hookah services by the restaurants within the State of Uttar Pradesh constitutes a flagrant violation of Rule 4(3) of the Prohibition of Smoking in Public Places Rules, 2008 as amended in 2017 and is in direct contravention of the scheme and object of COTPA.”

On enforcement, the Court held that the Food and Safety Department and Municipal Corporation lack jurisdiction to issue licences for regulating hookah bars in Uttar Pradesh. However, it said the police have powers under COTPA to ensure compliance, including powers to search, seize, confiscate and impose penalties where establishments violate the statutory requirements. The Court ultimately answered the central question before it in the negative:

“

“Upon sifting through the aforesaid principles this Court arrives at the unambiguous conclusion that the question that these writ petitions have posed before us as to whether hookah bars may lawfully operate and render hookah service in Designated Smoking Area within public places in the State of Uttar Pradesh is answered in the negative. This Court holds, accordingly, that the operation of hookah bars and the rendering of hookah services by the restaurants within the State of Uttar Pradesh constitutes a flagrant violation of Rule 4(3) of the Prohibition of Smoking in Public Places Rules, 2008 as amended in 2017 and is in direct contravention of the scheme and object of COTPA.”

All the writ petitions were accordingly dismissed. The Registry was directed to send a copy of the judgment to the Chief Secretary and Director General of Police, Uttar Pradesh, for information and necessary compliance.

Court urges UP to impose stringent punishment

In an extensive epilogue, the Court referred to tobacco-control measures adopted by other States, including Gujarat, Punjab, Rajasthan, Maharashtra and Karnataka, which have specifically banned hookah bars and increased penalties for violations.

The Bench also referred to India’s obligations under the WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control and observed that India’s smoke-free policy had been classified as “merely moderate” in the WHO’s 2019 Report on the Global Tobacco Epidemic. The Court then recorded its concerns regarding the health effects of hookah. It observed:

“

“A single session of hookah lasting approximately one hour involves an estimated 200 puffs and is equivalent in harm to smoking 100 cigarettes. It is a myth that hookah is less harmful than cigarettes. Hookah is as addictive as a cigarette, as harmful as a cigarette, and contains the same toxic chemicals as a cigarette.”

The Bench further noted that while cigarettes carry mandatory statutory health warnings, a similar caution for hookah is required to address what it described as a regulatory gap. In view of the health concerns associated with hookah, the Court said it expects the Uttar Pradesh Government to take necessary steps for the welfare of citizens, including issuing a notification imposing stringent punishment for serving hookah in designated smoking areas, on the lines of measures adopted by other States.

Justice Saraf’s personal note on tobacco smoking

The judgment concludes with a personal reflection by Justice Shekhar B. Saraf under the heading “My Experience With Tobacco Smoking.” The Judge said he was sharing his own experience to caution young people against developing the habit of tobacco smoking.

In a poem, Justice Saraf recounts how he initially viewed smoking as a weakness and believed he would never take it up, but eventually started smoking and saw what began as occasional use gradually turn into a regular habit. He describes repeatedly telling himself that he was in control, even as his consumption increased and attempts to quit failed.

Towards the end, Justice Saraf uses his own experience to caution young people that what may initially appear harmless can develop into an entrenched habit. He urges them not to dismiss the early warning signs of tobacco use and draws on his own experience to emphasise the difficulty of quitting once the habit takes hold.

Appearances

Counsel for Petitioners: Vatsala Singh, Nitesh Kumar Mishra, Shobhit Mohan Shukla Aarsh Raj, Abhay Pratap Singh, Abhilasha Rastogi, Abhishek Mishra, Abhishek Singh, Adarsh Pratap Singh, Ajay Kumar Singh, Ajeet Pratap Singh, Akansha Pathak, Akhileshwar Singh, Akriti Pandey, Aman Thakur, Anand Kumar, Anand Mishra, Anand Prakash Dixit, Anubhav Awasthi, Anuj Kumar Awasthi, Anuj Kumar Gupta, Anurag Singh, Arpit Verma, Arun Kumar Yadav, Aryan Singh, Ashish Kumar, Ashutosh Mishra, Atma Ram Mishra, Chandan Verma, Deepansi, Dharmendra Kumar Verma, Dhiraj Pratap Singh, Dinesh Kumar Mishra, Divya Dwivedi, Hari Krishna Chaubey, Harshit Singh, Harshita Rajnish, Indra Pratap Singh, Ishan Bhasin, Kamlesh Kumar Gupta, Kshemendra Shukla, Lakshmi Kant Tripathi, Mangal Sen Yadav, Manoj Kumar Mishra, Mohd. Imran Khan, Muskan Bharti, Neeta Tekwani, Nitesh Kumar Mishra, Palak Sahai Gupta, Pankaj Mishra, Pankaj Verma, Pawan Kumar Shukla, Piyush Tripathi, Prabhakar Trivedi, Prashant Mishra, Prerna Jalan, Raghvendra Pandey, Rahul Kumar, Raj Krishna, Rakesh Kumar Upadhyaya, Ratnesh Kumar Rawat, Ritic Bhardwaj, Ritick Bhardwaj, Sachin Dixit, Sagar Singh, Samanvya Dhar Dwivedi, Sanidhya Shukla, Sanjeev Kumar Dwivedi, Saurabh Kashyap, Shailendra Kumar Singh, Sheo Shankar Verma, Shikhar Chaube, Shivanshu Goswami, Shobh Nath Pandey, Shobhit Mohan Shukla, Sivendra Kumar Srivastav, Sudhanshu Singh, Suraj Sharma, Surya Bhan Singh, Sushil Kumar, Syed Aftab Ahmad, Syed Ahmad Mehdi, Tauheed, Vaibhav Srivastava, Vaibhav Upadhyay, Varsha Pandey, Vatsala Singh, Vineet Tripath

Counsel for Respondents: C.S.C., Akhilesh Kumar Srivastava Abha Srivastava, Adnan Hashmat, Aftab Ahmad, Akhilesh Kumar Srivastava, Anuj Kumar Srivastava, C.S.C., G.A., Jaiyesh Bhoosreddy, Krishna Kumar Pandey, Mohammad Talib Khan, Namit Sharma, Om Shankar Tiwari, Rajesh Kumar Singh, Shailendra Singh Chauhan, Shailesh Kumar Pathak, Shashwat Dwivedi, Shruti Sahu, Siddarth Tripathi, Siddharth Shankar Dubey, Siddharth Tripathi, Yatindra Pathak

PDF Icon

M/s Aftek Foods and Beverages Pvt. Ltd. vs State of U.P. & connected matters

Preview PDF