loader image

Karnataka HC: Section 34(c) of Stamp Act Allows Insufficiently Stamped Instruments to Be Admitted in Certain Criminal Proceedings

Karnataka HC: Section 34(c) of Stamp Act Allows Insufficiently Stamped Instruments to Be Admitted in Certain Criminal Proceedings

Sri Erigala Ram Pula Reddy v. M/s Grind Stone Crusher LLP [Decided on 12-11-2026]

Justice Anant Ramanath

In a criminal petition filed before the Karnataka High Court under Section 482 of the Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 (CrPC) to assail an order dated 23-12-2025 in a criminal revision petition on the file of the Additional Sessions Judge, Bangalore, as well as an order dated 25-06-2025 in a file before the VII Additional Judge and ACJM Court of Small Causes, Bengaluru, a Single Judge Bench of Justice Anant Ramanath Hegde dismissed the petition.

The respondent, M/s. Grind Stone Crusher LLP, filed a private complaint under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 against the proprietor of Sri. Lakshmi Venkateshwara Stone Crusher (petitioner). To substantiate its claim, the complainant produced a Memorandum of Understanding dated 19-09-2021. The accused objected to its admissibility on the ground that it was not adequately stamped as required under the Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957, and filed an application under Section 58(2) of the Act to reject the document.

The Trial Court rejected the application, holding that the MoU could be considered for a collateral purpose noting that no objection was raised when the document was marked and took exception to the application having been filed without an affidavit being accompanied only by a memorandum of facts. The Sessions Judge upheld the Magistrate’s order on different grounds, reasoning that, in view of proviso to Section 34 read with Section 58(1), admission of an instrument in evidence was not barred in criminal proceedings except those under Chapter XII and Chapter XXXVI of CrPC, and that Section 138 proceedings, being governed by Sections 262 to 265 under Chapter XXI, fell outside those chapters.

The petitioner argued that Sections 33 and 34 of the Act, read together, made an insufficiently stamped document inadmissible, that the insufficiency went to the root of the matter and was not cured merely because no objection was raised at the time of marking. It was also contended that clause (a) of the proviso to Section 33 gave the Magistrate no absolute discretion to refrain from examining the stamp duty and required valid reasons, which the Magistrate had not assigned.

The Court found that Section 33(1) mandated impounding of insufficiently stamped documents, while clause (a) of the proviso to Section 33(2) gave a Magistrate or Judge of a Criminal Court discretion not to examine or impound if he did not think fit to do so. It was stated that Section 33 did not deal with the admissibility or inadmissibility of the insufficiently stamped document. Further, the Court stated that clause (c) of Section 34 did not confer any discretion on the Magistrate or the Judge on the question of admissibility of an insufficiently stamped instrument which is sought to be tendered in evidence.

ALSO READ: Supreme Court Urges High Courts to Adopt Mechanism for Timely Uploading of Judgments

It was stated that if the case in which the document is tendered in evidence, does not fall under the chapter specifically named in the said clause, then in a criminal proceeding the document is admissible in evidence notwithstanding the fact that it is insufficiently stamped. The Court found the two provisions were not inconsistent and neither was redundant, since they operated in different fields and served different purposes and it was stated that if a document is impounded under Section 33(1), it does not mean that the documents are inadmissible in all circumstances, if the stamp duty and penalty is not paid as required under Section 34.

The Court held that such a document would be admissible in criminal proceedings other than those falling under the chapters named in clause (a) to proviso to Section 34. It was stated that in such event, the Magistrate or the Judge dealing with a criminal case not governed by the chapters specifically named in clause (a) of the proviso to Section 34 may bring the matter to the notice of the competent authority, to take steps for recovery of the stamp duty and penalty. Hence, the Court found no error in the Sessions Judge’s order, and although it was found that the Magistrate’s reasons might not have been correct, the order admitting the document and refusing to impound it was upheld.

It was concluded that Section 34(c) provided for the admissibility of an insufficiently stamped instrument in a criminal proceeding not falling under Chapter XII or XXXVI of CrPC, 1898. The Court stated that because of the repeal of the Code of 1898 by the Code of 1973, and of the Code of 1973 by the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita 2023, the corresponding chapters of the later enactments have to be read into Sections 33(1) and 34(c). The Court stated that in cases where Magistrate or Judge chooses to impound the instrument for want of sufficient stamp, even then, in a criminal proceeding not falling under the chapters specifically named in the said provisions, the insufficiently stamped document would be admissible.

Lastly, while dismissing the petition, the Court stated that the stamp duty or penalty legally viable can be recovered under Section 46, but payment of the stamp duty cannot be a condition precedent to admit the insufficiently stamped document in evidence.

ALSO READ: Madras High Court Refuses to Restrain OTT Release of Ajay Devgn’s ‘Dhrishyam: The Conclusion’

Appearances

For Petitioner – Mr. Jayakumar S Patil (Sr. Counsel), Mr. Anjaneya A B

For Respondent – Mr. Irshad Ahmed K

PDF Icon

Sri Erigala Ram Pula Reddy v. M/s Grind Stone Crusher LLP

Preview PDF