Holding that a unique combination of existing components can still qualify as a patentable invention, the Madras High Court has upheld the Patent No. 458805 for a round-bale twine-tying machine, finding no lack of novelty, inventive step, or disclosure. The Court held that although certain individual components were known in the industry, the patented combination itself was novel and technically distinct from prior art.
After examining all cited prior-art documents, the Court found none disclosed the patented combination of a chain drive, side backstop clutch, and density-triggered cutting mechanism. The Court observed that the relevant test is whether prior art teaches the specific combination and technical advancement claimed by the patent holder.
Since the specification adequately described the invention and the challengers themselves had understood its operation, the Court rejected the plea of incomplete disclosure. The Court clarified that failure to market or commercially work a patent does not attract revocation under Section 64 of the Patents Act and may instead be relevant only in the context of compulsory licensing provisions.
Briefly, the dispute arose after Ashlyn Antony obtained Patent No. 458805 titled“Baler for tying round bale using twine” on Oct 12, 2023. Subsequently, he issued a cease-and-desist notice alleging patent infringement by M/s. Bull Agro Implements and its partners. In response, the petitioners filed a revocation petition under Section 64 of the Patents Act, 1970, contending that the patented mechanism lacked novelty and inventive step, that similar bale-tying mechanisms had been publicly known and used in the agricultural industry for many years, and that the patent specification was insufficiently disclosed. The petitioners relied upon twelve prior-art documents to challenge the validity of the patent.
The patentee defended the grant by asserting that the invention was not a mere bale-tying mechanism but a unique combination comprising a chain drive on a link plate, a side backstop clutch that holds the twine for the next cycle, and a blade mounted beneath the clutch that cuts the twine at a predetermined bale density while also stopping its movement. According to the respondent, none of the cited prior-art references disclosed this particular combination or its technical effects.
Also read Supreme Court Urges High Courts to Adopt Mechanism for Timely Uploading of Judgments
A Single Judge Bench of Justice P.B. Balaji noted that the core question was whether the patented combination was already disclosed in prior art or would have been obvious to a person skilled in the field. The Court conducted a detailed comparison of all twelve prior-art references relied upon by the petitioners and found that none of them disclosed the specific combination claimed in the impugned patent.
While certain individual elements were known in the industry, the prior-art documents did not teach a mechanism integrating a side backstop clutch holding the twine for the next cycle and a blade positioned beneath it that cuts the twine upon reaching a predetermined bale density, added the Court.
The Court observed that even where similar baling or twine-cutting arrangements existed, they lacked crucial features found in the patented invention. It held that the invention demonstrated technical advancement and novelty over the cited references. Merely because some components were individually known did not mean that the patented combination itself lacked inventiveness.
On the challenge relating to insufficiency of disclosure, the Court found that the complete specification adequately described the structure, operation and claimed features of the invention. The Court also noted that the petitioners themselves had correctly understood the patented mechanism, which weakened their argument that the disclosure was inadequate. Further, no evidence was produced to show that a skilled person would be unable to reproduce the invention from the specification.
Addressing the argument that the patent had not been commercially worked, the Court observed that the patent had been granted only in October 2023 and the statutory period for filing working statements had not yet expired. It further held that non-working or non-marketing of a patent is not a ground for revocation under Section 64 of the Patents Act.
Appearances
For Appellants: Mr. Sruya Senthil and Shubham Mathew George for M/s. Surana & Surana
For Respondents: Mr. Dinesh Jothwani for R1, Mr. P.G. Santhosh Kumar, Senior Panel Counsel for R2

