Emphasising that separate deeds of hypothecation cannot defeat the substance of a guarantees, the New Delhi Bench of the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) has upheld the CIRP against four group companies, holding that obligations undertaken under loan documents made them corporate guarantors of the principal borrower.
The NCLAT ruled that merely describing a company as a ‘hypothecator’ is not decisive. If the loan documents create an obligation to repay a borrower’s debt upon default, the entity can be treated as a corporate guarantor. A contract of guarantee need not be contained in a single document. Courts can determine guarantor status by reading loan agreements and security documents together.
Where loan documents make an entity jointly and severally liable for repayment and require it to meet shortfalls from any source, such obligations may amount to a guarantee. Once CIRP against the principal borrower is pending before a particular NCLT, insolvency proceedings against its corporate guarantor must be filed before the same tribunal, notwithstanding the guarantor’s registered office being located elsewhere, added the Tribunal.
The NCLAT also said that since the arbitral awards remained unstayed and the debt remained unpaid, the financial creditor was entitled to rely upon those liabilities for initiation of CIRP.
Briefly, the appeals were filed by Bindu Kapoor, suspended director of four group companies, namely Imagine Estate Private Ltd, Imagine Home Private Ltd, Imagine Residence Private Ltd and Imagine Habitat Private Ltd, challenging a common order of the NCLT, New Delhi, which admitted all four companies into Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP) on petitions filed by J.C. Flowers Asset Reconstruction Pvt Ltd. under Section 7 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC). The financial creditor relied upon loan facilities granted to the principal borrower, Bliss House Private Limited (BHPL), and the hypothecation arrangements executed by the appellant companies in favour of the lender.
The appellant contended that the four companies were merely hypothecators of certain assets and had never executed any corporate guarantees in favour of the lender. It was argued that since their registered offices were situated in Mumbai, insolvency proceedings could only be initiated before the NCLT having territorial jurisdiction over Mumbai and not before NCLT, New Delhi.
The financial creditor, on the other hand, asserted that the loan documents and deeds of hypothecation imposed joint and several obligations on the appellant companies to repay the debt in case of default by BHPL. On this basis, it claimed that the companies were corporate guarantors and, therefore, Section 60(2) of the IBC permitted proceedings before the same NCLT where CIRP of the principal borrower was already pending.
The Coram comprising Justice Yogesh Khanna (Officiating Chairperson), Barun Mitra (Technical Member) and Ajai Das Mehrotra (Technical Member) noted that CIRP against Bliss House Private Limited had already been admitted and that such admission had attained finality after being upheld by both the NCLAT and the Supreme Court. Consequently, the only surviving issue was whether the appellant companies could be treated as corporate guarantors for the purpose of Section 60(2) of the IBC.
The Tribunal examined the loan agreements and found that the appellant companies were expressly included within the definition of “Obligors”. The loan documents made all obligors jointly and severally liable for repayment of the lender’s dues and further required them to discharge shortfalls from any source in the event of default. According to the Tribunal, these obligations went beyond a mere charge over hypothecated assets.
The NCLAT observed that the deeds of hypothecation could not be read in isolation. When read together with the loan agreements, they clearly demonstrated that the appellant companies had undertaken liability to repay the debt upon default by the principal borrower. Therefore, the substance of the arrangement indicated a guarantee obligation notwithstanding the nomenclature adopted in the documents.
Relying on the Supreme Court’s decision in China Development Bank v. Doha Bank QPSC [(2025) 7 Supreme Court Cases 729], the Tribunal held that the title of a document is not decisive. What is relevant is whether the covenants contained in the document create an obligation to discharge another person’s debt upon default. The covenant requiring payment of the lender’s dues and recovery of any shortfall was held to possess the essential characteristics of a guarantee.
The Tribunal further rejected the argument that absence of a single tripartite document or signatures of all parties on one instrument defeats a guarantee. Referring to Punjab National Bank v. Shri Vikram Cotton Mills [(1970) 1 SCC 60], it observed that a guarantee can be inferred from multiple agreements read together, from conduct of the parties, and even from oral arrangements where the intention to stand as surety is clear.
The Tribunal also emphasised that Section 60(2) of the IBC overrides the general territorial jurisdiction rule under Section 60(1). Since CIRP of the principal borrower, BHPL, was already pending before NCLT, New Delhi, insolvency proceedings against its corporate guarantors were required to be heard by the same Tribunal to avoid conflicting decisions and ensure consistency in adjudication.
Appearances
For Appellants: Mr. Krishnendu Datta, Sr. Advocate with Mr. Abhay Chattopadhyay, Mr. Udipto Koushik Sarmah, Mr. Kumar Shubham, Mr. Harsh Gurbani, Advocates.
For Respondents: Mr. Sandeep Bajaj, Ms. Aakanksha Nehra, Mr. Shubham Jaiswal, Ms. Sanya Mann, Advocates for R-1 along with Ms. Mamta Binani, RP-in person.
Mr. Abhijeet Sinha, Sr. Advocate with Mr. Ritesh Kumar, Mr. Sidhant Kumar Marwah, Mr. Jasmeet Singh, Mr. Shivam Sharan, Mr. Pushpendra Kumar, Mr. Naman Gowda, Mr. Siddhant Ahirwal, Ms. Lahar Jain and Ms. Ekssha Kashyap, Advocates for R-2.

