The Karnataka High Court (Bengaluru Bench) has permitted Nimishamba Devasthana to seek Section 12A registration from the date it was notified as a religious institution under State law, and fresh opportunity to contest reassessment proceedings. The Court noted the temple’s claim that its income comprised only hundi collections, seva receipts and interest income, and held that these aspects require proper examination before any tax liability is fastened.
The High Court held that the temple cannot be denied an opportunity to seek registration under Section 12A from the date it was notified as a religious and charitable institution under the Karnataka Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments Act, 1997. It is said that if the competent authority grants retrospective registration after examining the temple’s records and legal submissions, the benefit may be considered while framing fresh assessments.
Briefly, the petitioner, Nimishamba Devasthana, a temple at Ganjam in Mandya district, challenged two reassessment orders passed by the Income Tax Department for Assessment Years 2017-18 and 2020-21. The temple contended that it is a religious and charitable institution whose income primarily consists of hundi collections, seva receipts from devotees, and interest earned on surplus deposits. It argued that the assessment orders were passed ex parte without adequate participation from its side.
The temple also sought a direction to grant registration under Sections 12A/12AA of the Income Tax Act with retrospective effect from 29 September 2012, the date on which it was notified as a religious and charitable institution under the Karnataka Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments Act, 1997. It relied on the doctrine of ‘substance over form’ to contend that the benefit of registration should relate back to the date of such notification.
A Single Judge Bench of Justice B M Shyam Prasad observed that the impugned assessment orders had been passed ex parte and that the temple must be given an effective opportunity to respond to the reassessment proceedings. The Court noted the temple’s claim that its receipts consisted only of hundi collections and seva charges and that these aspects deserved examination on merits before any tax liability was finalized.
The Court further observed that if the receipts of the temple for Assessment Years 2017-18 and 2020-21 were subjected to tax, while similar receipts in the intervening years had not been taxed, such circumstances warranted a proper reconsideration of the matter after granting an opportunity of hearing.
The Court also held that the temple could not be denied the opportunity to approach the Commissioner of Income Tax (Exemptions) seeking registration under Section 12A with effect from the date of its notification under the Karnataka law. If such registration were granted after examining relevant records, accounts, and legal submissions, the outcome could have a bearing on the reassessment proceedings and therefore deserved consideration before fresh assessments were framed.
Appearances
For Petitioner: Poornima H S., Advocate
For Respondent: M. Thirumalesh., Advocate along with Nirmal Mathew., Advocate

