The New Delhi Bench of the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) has held that liability under a corporate guarantee is co-extensive with that of the principal borrower, and a financial creditor is not required to first exhaust remedies against the principal borrower before proceeding against the guarantor under Section 7 of the IBC. Thus, allegations regarding release of securities, fraud, management disputes, Section 185 violations, account certification, and pending civil proceedings were held insufficient to rebut the documentary evidence establishing debt and default.
Even though no funds were directly disbursed to Mahamaya Exports Private Limited, its guarantees for loans granted to ABW Infrastructure Limited created a financial debt within the meaning of Section 5(8) of the IBC. The Tribunal held that the principal borrower’s letter dated Feb 27, 2017, acknowledging continuing liability saved limitation, particularly because the guarantee deed treated such acknowledgment as binding on the guarantor as well.
Participation of Indian Bank (Erstwhile Allahabad Bank) in the borrower’s CIRP and simultaneous enforcement of guarantee obligations did not amount to double recovery or abuse of process. Any recoveries received would simply require accounting adjustments, added the Tribunal.
Briefly, the Indian Bank (Erstwhile Allahabad Bank) filed a Section 7 application under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 against Mahamaya Exports Private Limited, contending that the company had executed multiple corporate guarantees to secure various credit facilities extended to the principal borrower, ABW Infrastructure Limited. Following defaults in repayment, the borrower account was classified as NPA on Sep 29, 2016. The Bank subsequently issued a demand notice under the SARFAESI Act and sought initiation of CIRP against the corporate guarantor for outstanding dues exceeding the statutory threshold.
The Bank originally claimed over Rs. 31.37 crore but later revised the claim after excluding expired and uninvoked bank guarantees. The surviving claim comprised dues under two term loan accounts amounting to about Rs. 21.99 crore, apart from legal expenses. The Bank also relied upon a letter dated Feb 27, 2017, issued by the principal borrower acknowledging continuing liabilities in the loan accounts.
The corporate debtor opposed the petition on several grounds, including that no amount had been directly disbursed to it, the Bank was already participating in the CIRP of the principal borrower, the claim was time-barred, some guarantees did not cover the disputed facilities, and that release of certain secured properties discharged the guarantor’s liability. It also raised allegations concerning fraud, management disputes, Section 185 of the Companies Act, and misuse of the insolvency process.
The Division Bench comprising Manni Sankariah Shanmuga Sundaram (Judicial Member), Reena Sinha Puri (Technical Member) observed that Section 5(8)(i) of the IBC specifically includes liabilities arising from guarantees within the definition of ‘financial debt’. Therefore, a corporate guarantor need not receive direct disbursement of funds for a financial debt to arise. The Tribunal also recognised the co-extensive liability of a corporate guarantor and permits proceedings under Section 7 against the guarantor.
The Tribunal found that the record contained valid corporate guarantees executed on different dates, including a guarantee dated April 30, 2012, covering aggregate facilities of Rs. 48.35 crores. This sufficiently addressed the guarantor’s argument that certain loan facilities were not covered by any guarantee.
On limitation, the Tribunal held that the application was filed within time. It noted that before expiry of the limitation period, the principal borrower had issued the acknowledgment letter dated Feb 27, 2017, admitting continuing liability in the outstanding loan accounts. Further, the guarantee documents expressly provided that an acknowledgment or part-payment by the borrower would be treated as having been made on behalf of the guarantor as well. Consequently, the Section 7 petition filed on Feb 26, 2020, was held to be within limitation.
The Tribunal further observed that the Bank’s participation in the CIRP of the principal borrower did not extinguish the separate liability of the corporate guarantor. A creditor is entitled to proceed simultaneously against both the borrower and the guarantor, subject to adjustment of any recoveries to prevent double recovery.
The NCLT rejected the contention that reversal of bank-guarantee entries defeated the insolvency case. It noted that those entries had already been removed from the revised claim and that substantial defaults under the term loan facilities remained outstanding. Similarly, objections relating to release of the Kapashera property, pending civil litigation, alleged fraud, company-law disputes, and Section 185 issues were found insufficient to dislodge the documentary evidence establishing debt and default.
The Tribunal also declined the corporate debtor’s request for action against the Bank under Sections 65, 72 and 75 of the IBC, holding that the Bank’s use of SARFAESI proceedings, participation in the borrower’s CIRP, and invocation of the corporate guarantee were legally permissible remedies and did not indicate any fraudulent or malicious intent.
Appearances
For Applicants: Mr. Anant Gautam, Mr. Aman Gahlot, Ms. Isha Gaur, Ms. Himanshi Chugh, Advs.
For Respondents: Mr. J. Rajesh, Md. Arsalan Ahmed, Mr. Yashwardhan Aggarwal, Mr. Ali Abbas Masoodi, Advs.

