The Supreme Court on Friday directed its Secretary General to conduct a fact-finding inquiry into why the Enforcement Directorate’s petition challenging the bail granted to Raman Singla remained unlisted for more than three years despite notice having been issued in 2023. A Bench comprising Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V. Mohana sought an explanation from the Registry over the prolonged delay and directed that a report be submitted on the circumstances leading to the non-listing of the matter. CJI observed:
“
“The only thing we need to inquire about is who is that magic man, that a notice is issued and for 3 years the matter does not appear in the list. The great registry needs to explain to us….These matters were never listed for 3 years. When a fresh matter came, then we directed that these matters be listed. For 3 years, who managed it, we’ll find out. The great registry needs to explain to us.”
The Court disposed of the Enforcement Directorate’s plea challenging the bail order, observing that the trial had already commenced and eight witnesses had been examined. The Court was not inclined to entertain the petition at this stage and clarified that the impugned order would neither be treated as a precedent nor influence the outcome of the pending trial.
Senior Advocate Siddharth Dave, appearing for the respondent, disagreed with the suggestion that matters could be managed in the Registry, stating that the Supreme Court was fully computerised. Senior Advocate Zoheb Hossain then remarked that Mr Dave had not been as involved with the Registry as an Advocate-on-Record. Dave responded that he had been practising for twice as long as Mr Hossain. He said:
“
“I have been here twice the number of years you have practiced Mr. Hossain. In 1990, my Lord Justice Mohana has also been here. She has practiced here. My Lord Justice Bagchi and the Honorable Chief Justice used to be here.”
Senior Advocate Siddharth Dave also suggested that the matter may not have been listed due to changes in the composition or availability of Benches. However, the CJI questioned this explanation, observing that Benches were available.
On the merits, the Court noted that the trial had already progressed, with eight witnesses examined, and declined to entertain the ED’s plea at this stage. While disposing of the petition, the Bench accepted the request that the impugned order should not be treated as a precedent and should have no impact on the trial’s outcome.

