The Supreme Court, while deciding a cross-border child custody dispute between an Indian father and a German mother, expressed concern that the father’s demanding professional commitments as a practising lawyer could affect his ability to devote adequate personal time to their four-year-old son. The Court observed that a young child requires considerable personal attention, particularly in preparing for school, assisting with homework and supporting extracurricular activities.
The Bench of Justice N. Kotiswar Singh noted that the father runs a busy law firm in Delhi employing approximately 53 associates, with professional engagements extending to Goa, Mumbai and Bengaluru. Although the father claimed to have a flexible schedule, the Court was sceptical that he would be able to provide the child with sufficient quality time. It expressed concern that he would likely have to depend on relatives and nannies, thereby delegating a significant portion of parental responsibilities to others. In contrast, the Court found the mother’s proposed arrangement more realistic, noting that she had produced her employer’s Work-from-Home policy and endorsement demonstrating her ability to adjust her working hours to personally attend to the child.
The Court also noted that the mother had initiated the child’s admission process at the United World College of South East Asia (UWCSEA) in Singapore and identified alternative schools, whereas the father had not produced concrete documents demonstrating any admission arrangements for the child’s proposed schooling in Kolkata. Further, the NIMHANS assessment did not find any diagnosable mental health condition in the mother or behaviour detrimental to the child’s well-being. The Court emphasised that the child’s lack of formal schooling and the absence of a structured environment were affecting his development and stability.
Rejecting the father’s objection to the Supreme Court exercising jurisdiction while guardianship proceedings were pending before the Family Court, Patiala House, New Delhi, the Court held that it could decide the question of interim custody in exercise of its parens patriae jurisdiction in habeas corpus proceedings. It clarified that the habeas corpus proceedings concerned interim custody, whereas the Family Court would continue to determine permanent guardianship. Holding that the mother had a better prima facie claim to custody, that the balance of convenience favoured her and that the child could suffer irreparable injury if interim custody was not granted, the Court permitted her to take the child to Singapore for education.
However, to protect the father’s visitation rights and ensure compliance with the Indian proceedings, the Court directed the mother to obtain a mirror order from an appropriate Singapore court within three weeks. Upon filing the mirror order, she would be required to deposit ₹1 crore with the Supreme Court Registry in an interest-bearing fixed deposit as security for compliance with the directions until final disposal of the guardianship proceedings, including any appeals, reviews or revisions.
The Court further directed the mother to enrol the child at UWCSEA or an alternative school identified in her parenting plan, while requiring the father to provide the necessary documents and cooperation for admission. The mother would have primary responsibility for the child’s health and physical well-being in Singapore. The father would be entitled to daily video-conferencing with the child for at least 20 minutes, besides physical visitation and custody during his visits to Singapore, subject to the child’s school schedule. The mother was also directed to bring the child to India during school vacations exceeding seven days to enable him to spend time with his father, paternal family and friends.
The Court clarified that these arrangements are interim in nature and would remain subject to the final determination of the guardianship proceedings before the Family Court.
Appearances
For Petitioner(s) : Ms. Geeta Luthra, Sr. Adv.; Mr. Aadarsh Kothari, Adv.; Ms. Janvi Desai, Adv.; Ms. Prachi Sharma, Adv.; Ms. Shagufa Salim, AOR; Mr. Hariom, Adv.
For Respondent(s) : Mr. Omkar Jayant Deshpande- 3920, AOR; Mr. Chandan Goswami, Adv.; Mr. Nrupal Dingankar, Adv.
Mr. Gopal Sankaranarayanan, Sr. Adv.; Ms. Malavika Rajkotia, Adv.; Mr. Pradyut Kashyap, Adv.; Ms. Purva Dua, Adv.; Mr. Madhav Gupta, Adv.; Ms. Ritika Sethi, Adv.; Mr. Vishal Prasad- 2178, AOR

