loader image

Parle Biscuits Wins; CESTAT Holds Captively Consumed Sugar Syrup in Biscuit Manufacturing Not Excisable Without Proof of Marketability

Parle Biscuits Wins; CESTAT Holds Captively Consumed Sugar Syrup in Biscuit Manufacturing Not Excisable Without Proof of Marketability

Parle Biscuits vs Commissioner of Central Excise, Goods & Service Tax [Decided on November 13, 2026]

Marketability of Captively Consumed Sugar Syrup

Emphasising that marketability cannot be presumed merely because similar sugar syrups are sold by other manufacturers, the Chandigarh Bench of the Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT) has granted relief to Parle Biscuits and held that Excise Department Cannot Classify Sugar Syrup Under Tariff Heading 1702 90 90 Without Establishing 50% Fructose Content.

Finding that the Revenue failed to establish the fructose percentage through any conclusive test, the Tribunal pointed out that CRCL report was insufficient to support the Department’s case, as it only reported invert sugar content and did not determine the actual fructose percentage necessary for classification.

Captively consumed intermediate products remain eligible for exemption under Notification No. 67/95-CE where the manufacturer complies with Rule 6 of the CENVAT Credit Rules by not availing or reversing credit, added the Tribunal.

Also read High Time that Legislature Considers Amendment in Statutes Dealing with Juveniles and Children in Conflict with Law to Reduce Age to 16 Years: Kerala HC

Briefly, Parle Biscuits Pvt Ltd. manufactures biscuits and, during the manufacturing process, prepares sugar syrup by mixing sugar, water and a small quantity of citric acid. The sugar syrup is used captively within the factory for making biscuits and is not sold separately. After biscuits priced up to Rs. 100 per kg became fully exempt from Central Excise duty, the company stopped paying duty on the intermediate sugar syrup, claiming that the syrup was not marketable and therefore not excisable. The Department, however, treated the syrup as a dutiable intermediate product, denied exemption under Notification No. 67/95-CE, and raised duty demands along with penalties.

The Revenue relied upon CBEC circulars, a CRCL test report and examples of invert sugar syrup available in the market to contend that the product was marketable and classifiable under Tariff Heading 1702 90 90. The assessee argued that its sugar syrup was specially prepared for captive use, lacked independent marketability, did not contain the required fructose content for the proposed classification, and in any event remained eligible for Notification No. 67/95-CE because it had not availed, or had reversed, the relevant CENVAT credit.

Also read Temple Cannot Be Denied Tax Exemption Through Ex Parte Order Without Fair Hearing: Karnataka HC Allows Nimishamba Devasthana’s Retrospective Section 12A Registration

The Division Bench comprising Somesh Arora (Judicial Member) and P. Anjani Kumar (Technical Member) observed that merely showing that similar sugar or invert sugar syrups are sold in the market is insufficient. The Department must establish that the specific product manufactured by the assessee is chemically comparable and marketable in the condition in which it emerges. No such comparative evidence was produced by the Revenue.

The Bench further noted that the CRCL report only stated the percentage of invert sugar, sucrose and acidity. It did not determine the precise fructose content, which was crucial because classification under Tariff Heading 1702 90 90 requires sugar syrup blends containing at least 50% fructose by weight in the dry state. Therefore, the Department failed to substantiate the proposed classification.

The Tribunal accepted the contention that invert sugar consists of equal proportions of glucose and fructose. Even on the basis of the CRCL findings showing 79.9% invert sugar, the fructose content could not exceed about 40%, making the Revenue’s classification under Heading 1702 90 90 unsustainable.

Also read NCLAT: Hypothecator Can Be Treated as Corporate Guarantor if Loan Documents Create Liability to Repay Borrower’s Debt

The Bench also observed that the Revenue did not dispute the assessee’s claim that it had either not availed CENVAT credit or had reversed the credit in accordance with Rule 6 of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004. Consequently, the benefit of Notification No. 67/95-CE remained available to the captively consumed intermediate product.

Additionally, the Tribunal reiterated the settled principle that there can be no estoppel against law in taxation matters. Therefore, the fact that the assessee had paid duty on the product in an earlier period could not create a legal liability if the product was otherwise not liable to duty.

The Bench relied heavily upon its earlier decisions, particularly Rishi Bakers and subsequent cases, where similar sugar syrup used in biscuit manufacturing had been held to be neither properly classifiable under Heading 1702 90 90 nor proven to be marketable.

Appearances

Mr. Jatin Mahajan, Advocate for the Appellants

Mr. Goverdhan Dass Bansal, Authorized Representative for the Respondent

PDF Icon

Parle Biscuits vs Commissioner of Central Excise, Goods & Service Tax

Preview PDF