Holding Shapoorji Pallonji entitled to 6% interest on delayed GST refunds, the Vijayawada Bench of the Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT) has ruled that Department cannot avoid interest liability merely because refund was released within 60 days of consequential application filed after appellate relief. The GSTAT clarified that interest under Section 56 of the CGST Act starts running after 60 days from the date of the original refund application, and not from a fresh application filed after a favourable appellate order.
A fresh application filed pursuant to an appellate order merely facilitates implementation of the refund order and does not wipe out the taxpayer’s accrued right to interest. Thus, the Tribunal ruled that a taxpayer cannot be denied statutory compensation for delayed refund merely because the Department had wrongly rejected the claim and the refund was later allowed in appeal.
The GSTAT clarified that even where the Department processes the consequential refund application within the prescribed period, interest for the delay occurring after the original refund application remains payable. Thus, the Tribunal directed computation of statutory interest at the notified rate of 6% per annum on eligible refund amounts from the expiry of 60 days after the original refund applications till actual refund disbursement.
Briefly, the case concerns eight GST refund claims filed by Shapoorji Pallonji and Company Private Limited under the inverted duty structure for tax periods between December 2018 and March 2020. The refund applications were filed between January and March 2023 but were rejected by the tax authorities on the ground that the company was allegedly ineligible for refund under the applicable notification relating to construction services.
The company challenged the rejection orders before the First Appellate Authority. By orders dated 23 September 2023, the appellate authority set aside the refund rejections and allowed the refund claims. Following these appellate orders, the company filed consequential refund applications seeking release of the refund amounts along with statutory interest under Section 56 of the CGST Act.
Although the refund amounts were subsequently sanctioned and paid in November 2023, the authorities rejected the claim for interest. The Department took the stand that since the refunds had been sanctioned within sixty days of the consequential applications filed after the appellate orders, no interest was payable. The dispute before the GST Appellate Tribunal was whether interest should be calculated from the original refund applications or only from the consequential applications filed after the appellate relief.
The Quorum comprising Bhaskar Reddy Vemireddy (Judicial Member) and Satish Agrawal (Technical Member) observed that Section 56 of the CGST Act links the payment of ordinary statutory interest to the original refund application filed under Section 54(1). Merely because a refund claim was wrongly rejected and later allowed in appeal does not erase the taxpayer’s entitlement to interest for the earlier period of delay.
The Tribunal held that a consequential refund application filed pursuant to an appellate order is primarily a procedural requirement for implementing the appellate decision and disbursing the refund. It does not replace the original refund application for the purpose of calculating interest under Section 56.
The Tribunal observed that statutory interest is intended to compensate a taxpayer for being deprived of money legally due to it. A taxpayer’s entitlement to interest cannot be defeated merely because the Department had earlier passed an erroneous order rejecting the refund claim.
The Tribunal further observed that the proviso to Section 56, which provides for a higher rate of interest where a refund consequent to an appellate order is delayed beyond sixty days, does not extinguish the taxpayer’s right to ordinary interest under the main provision. The proviso only creates an additional category of enhanced interest and cannot be interpreted to deprive the taxpayer of interest that had already accrued from the original refund application.
The Tribunal also noted that Rule 93 of the CGST Rules and CBIC Circular No. 111/30/2019-GST indicate that an original refund claim continues to retain legal significance during appellate proceedings. Therefore, the Department cannot deny interest solely because the principal refund was released within sixty days of the consequential application.
Appearances
Anshul Jain, Founding Partner, Prowise Legal, on behalf of the Appellant

