loader image

Mere Relocation of Known Device Not Patentable Innovation; Madras HC Upholds Rejection of TVS Patent Application For Biometric User Recognition System

Mere Relocation of Known Device Not Patentable Innovation; Madras HC Upholds Rejection of TVS Patent Application For Biometric User Recognition System

TVS Motor Company Limited vs Deputy Controller of Patents and Designs [Decided on November 12, 2026]

Biometric Patent Inventive Step

The Madras High Court has ruled that shifting a biometric authentication system from an existing location to the fuel tank assembly may offer advantages, but cannot constitute an inventive step when prior art already discloses the same technology. Accordingly, the Court upheld the refusal of TVS Motor Company Limited’s patent application relating to a vehicle fitted with a biometric user recognition system.

The claimed invention primarily involved mounting the biometric authentication system on the fuel tank assembly, whereas prior art documents had disclosed similar systems in other vehicle locations. The Court held that even if the new placement offered ergonomic or operational benefits, such advantages by themselves do not transform a known technology into a patentable invention.

The High Court found that prior art documents D1 and D2 already disclosed substantially identical biometric authentication systems, making the claimed modification obvious to a person skilled in the art. Simply relocating an existing component to another part of a vehicle, without demonstrating a genuine technical advancement beyond prior art, does not satisfy the statutory requirement of an inventive step.

Also read NCLT: Coal Supplier Cannot Become Financial Creditor Merely Through MoU, Interest Clause or Mortgage Security

Briefly, the dispute arose from a patent application filed by TVS Motor Company Limited for an invention titled “A Vehicle”, relating to a two-wheeler equipped with a biometric user recognition system, such as fingerprint, voice, or retina recognition. The invention proposed mounting the biometric authentication device on the top surface of the fuel tank assembly, between the handlebar and the rider’s seat. According to the applicant, this placement improved rider accessibility, simplified wiring, enhanced wiring durability, and made the system more secure against tampering and theft.

During examination, the Deputy Controller of Patents and Designs raised objections regarding inventive step and patentability. Although some objections were later dropped, the patent application was ultimately refused on the grounds that the invention lacked an inventive step under Section 2(1)(ja) of the Patents Act and amounted to a mere arrangement or rearrangement of known devices under Section 3(f).

Also read Madras High Court Refuses to Restrain OTT Release of Ajay Devgn’s ‘Dhrishyam: The Conclusion’

A Single Judge Bench of Justice K. Kumaresh Babu noted that the appellant itself acknowledged the existence of similar biometric authentication systems in the prior art documents D1 and D2. The only distinguishing feature claimed by the applicant was the placement of the biometric device on the fuel tank assembly instead of the locations disclosed in the prior art.

The Court observed that a technical advantage or a more convenient arrangement by itself does not automatically transform an existing technology into a new invention. While the new placement may offer certain advantages, such advantages arising from a known prior art cannot, by themselves, establish patentability.

Also read Bilkis Bano Gangrape Case: Supreme Court Suspends Life Sentences Of Two Convicts, Grants Them Bail

The Court further held that prior art documents D1 and D2 were highly relevant because they disclosed substantially similar biometric authentication systems. The mere relocation of the biometric identification device from one part of the vehicle to another could not negate the effect of the prior art references.

Agreeing with the Patent Controller’s reasoning, the Court found that a person skilled in the art would consider such relocation of the biometric device to be obvious. Consequently, the invention did not satisfy the requirement of an inventive step.

Appearances

For Petitioners: Mr. Damodar Vaidya for Mrs. Deepika Murali

For Respondents: Mr. A.R. Sakthivel SPCGSC

PDF Icon

TVS Motor Company Limited vs Deputy Controller of Patents and Designs

Preview PDF