Where deceased co-defendants had already performed their contractual obligations and the suit was thereafter confined to the remaining defendant’s share, no right to sue survived against their legal representatives, held the Bombay High Court while quashing the trial court’s order framing an issue on abatement of the entire suit. The Court held that after certain defendants had executed conveyance deeds pursuant to a settlement, no enforceable right or liability survived against them at the time of their death. Consequently, there was no need to implead their legal representatives.
Order XXII Rule 4 CPC ordinarily causes abatement only against the deceased defendant. Abatement of the entire suit arises only where no effective decree can be passed in the absence of the deceased party’s legal representatives. Since Defendant Nos. 1 and 2 had already executed conveyances in favour of the plaintiff during their lifetime, the Court found that the contractual obligations qua them stood discharged.
The Court reiterated that there is no prohibition on agreements concerning undivided interests in property, and courts may grant specific performance regarding such shares, leaving consequential partition remedies to be worked out separately. Thus, the High Court held that the additional issue concerning abatement would unnecessarily widen the scope of the trial and distract from the real controversy, namely whether the plaintiff was entitled to specific performance against the sole remaining defendant.
Briefly, the dispute arose from a suit for specific performance filed by Evershine Builders Private Limited against the heirs of the original landowner in respect of agricultural land situated at Vasai. The builder claimed that an MoU dated 1 June 1996 and a subsequent Agreement for Sale dated 26 August 1997 were executed for sale of the suit properties and substantial consideration was paid. During the pendency of the suit, most of the defendants entered into consent terms with the plaintiff and executed conveyance deeds in respect of their aggregate 23/24th share in the property. As a result, the suit ultimately survived only against Hiren Jaswant Rajani (original Defendant No.6) concerning his share in the property.
Subsequently, Defendant Nos. 1 and 2 died. Their legal representatives were not brought on record within the prescribed period. Defendant No.6 therefore sought dismissal of the suit on the ground that it had abated. Although the trial court had earlier rejected that plea and permitted amendment of the plaint to confine the case to Defendant No.6 alone, it later framed an additional issue asking whether the entire suit had abated because the legal representatives of the deceased defendants had not been impleaded.
A Single Judge Bench of Justice N.J. Jamadar observed that under Order XXII Rule 4 CPC, non-substitution of legal representatives ordinarily results in abatement only against the deceased defendant. Abatement of the entire suit can occur only where the right to sue does not survive against the remaining defendants and no effective decree can be passed in their absence.
The Court emphasized that before considering abatement, it must first be seen whether any surviving right or liability existed against the deceased defendants on the date of their death. Referring to Section 306 of the Indian Succession Act and Section 37 of the Indian Contract Act, the Court noted that only those rights and obligations that exist at the time of death pass on to legal representatives.
In the present case, Defendant Nos. 1 and 2 had already executed conveyance deeds in favour of the plaintiff pursuant to the settlement and had performed their part of the bargain during their lifetime. The plaint had also been amended, and the suit had been restricted solely to the share of Defendant No.6. Therefore, no subsisting cause of action survived against the legal representatives of Defendant Nos. 1 and 2 after their deaths.
The Court further observed that merely because the original contract related to an undivided property, it did not follow that the entire suit would become non-maintainable. There is no legal bar against an agreement for sale of an undivided share in property, and courts can grant specific performance with respect to such share, leaving the purchaser to work out partition remedies separately.
Appearances
Mr. Karl Tamboly, with Karan Bhide, Nitesh Ranavat (V.C.), Vedant Joshi (V.C.) and Dhanashree, i/b Wadia Ghandy & Co, for the Petitioner.
Ms. Aafreen S Shaikh, i/b Krupali H Rajani, for the Respondent.

