loader image

Trademark Rights Cannot Be Revived By Next Generation’s Discovery; Bombay High Court Flags Registration Granted To Dead Person

Trademark Rights Cannot Be Revived By Next Generation’s Discovery; Bombay High Court Flags Registration Granted To Dead Person

Varun Atulya Mafatlal vs Shree Vallabh Chandak [Decided on November 19, 2026]

Justice Somasekhar Sundaresan

While dismissing a grandson’s challenge to the transfer of the ‘Sungrace Mafatlal’ trademarks on limitation grounds, the Bombay High Court has found serious irregularities in the Trade Marks Registry’s actions and initiated suo motu rectification proceedings over registrations granted after the original applicant’s death. The Court held that a legal heir inherits a cause of action along with its defects, delays and limitation consequences. A fresh limitation period does not begin merely because the successor personally discovered the issue later.

The High Court held that the three-year limitation period began when the impugned entries were made in the Trade Marks Register in 2018 and not when the petitioner claimed to have learnt about them in 2023. The Court noted that the Trade Marks Registry granted registration in the name of Madhuri Mafatlal in 2017 even though she had died in 2013 and the Registry had been informed of her death in 2015.

The Court held that Rule 55 of the 2017 Rules and Rule 61 of the 2002 Rules are not merely enabling provisions but impose a duty on the Registrar to ascertain the successor-in-interest before proceeding further with the application. Despite rejecting the petition as time-barred, the Court invoked its powers under Section 57(4) of the Trade Marks Act and initiated independent rectification proceedings to examine whether the registrations themselves should be cancelled.

Also read Gangsters Act Cannot Be Invoked For Excise Duty Evasion Case Absent Proof Of Violence/ Organised Gang Activity: Allahabad HC Quashes FIR In Saharanpur Liquor Case

Briefly, the dispute concerned the trademarks “SUNGRACE MAFATLAL” registered in Classes 24 and 25. Varun Atulya Mafatlal, grandson of the original applicant Madhuri Mafatlal, sought rectification of the Trade Marks Register by removing entries in favour of Malavika Taktawala and subsequently Shree Vallabh Chandak. He contended that the marks formed part of the Mafatlal family legacy and had been transferred based on un-probated wills and without following the procedure prescribed under trademark law.

The record showed that Madhuri had applied for registration of the marks in 2011 but died in 2013. Despite being informed of her death in 2015, the Trade Marks Registry granted registration in her name in 2017. Thereafter, the Registry recorded Malavika as successor proprietor in July 2018 and, soon after, recorded Chandak as proprietor pursuant to assignment deeds executed by Malavika.

Varun claimed that he became aware of Chandak’s ownership only in August 2023 and therefore filed the rectification petition in December 2023. Chandak opposed the petition primarily on the ground of limitation, contending that the challenged entries had been made in 2018 and were publicly available on the Trade Marks Register.

Also read Old Grant Land Belongs To Union, Not Occupancy Holder; Bombay HC Clarifies That Government Cannot Be Treated As Tenant In Eviction Suit

A Single Judge Bench of Justice Somasekhar Sundaresan first observed that Varun qualified as a “person aggrieved” under Section 57 of the Trade Marks Act. Being a direct descendant of the original applicant and claiming an interest in marks bearing the Mafatlal family name, he had sufficient locus to invoke the Court’s rectification jurisdiction.

However, the Court found considerable difficulty in accepting Varun’s argument that limitation should begin only from his alleged discovery of the entries in 2023. The Court noted that his father, Atulya Mafatlal, through whom Varun derived his rights, was alive when the registrations and transfers were made between 2017 and 2018 and took no action during his lifetime. The Court observed that Atulya and other family members were already engaged in multiple succession disputes and therefore could reasonably be expected to have exercised diligence regarding valuable family intellectual property.

The Court emphasised that limitation cannot be revived with every new generation claiming ignorance of earlier events. A successor inherits not only the rights of his predecessor but also the legal limitations, delays, acquiescence, and weaknesses attached to those rights. The Court therefore rejected the contention that Varun’s personal knowledge in 2023 could restart the limitation period.

Also read 70:30 Solar EPC Tax Formula Cannot Be Applied Retrospectively; Supreme Court Quashes Rs. 53-Crore GST Demand On Sterling & Wilson

At the same time, the Court expressed serious concern over the conduct of the Trade Marks Registry. It observed that the Registry granted registration in the name of a person who had died nearly four years earlier despite having notice of her death. The Court found no material showing that the Registry had followed the mandatory process of determining the successor-in-interest before proceeding with registration.

The Court stated that granting registration to a deceased person undermines the integrity of the Trade Marks Register. It noted that Rule 61 of the 2002 Rules and Rule 55 of the 2017 Rules were enacted precisely to address situations where an applicant dies before registration, and these provisions could not be ignored as mere discretionary powers.

The Court also found several unanswered questions surrounding the succession documents relied upon before the Registrar. It observed that one of the marks did not appear to have been specifically bequeathed under Madhuri’s Will, raising doubts about the subsequent transmission and assignment that ultimately led to Chandak’s registration.

Appearances

Abhineet Sharma & Ms Riya Gokalgandhi i/b. K.R. Parekh, Adv. For Petitioner/Applicant.

Mr. Sharan Jagtiani, Senior Advocate a/w. Mr. Amit Jajoo, Priyank Kapadia a/w. Amit J., Vedant Chhajed & Arjun Deshmukh i/b. Trilegal, for Respondent No.1.

Mr. Nikhil Kumar Rungta a/w. Mr. Jayesh Ramgiri, for Respondent No.2.

PDF Icon

Varun Atulya Mafatlal vs Shree Vallabh Chandak

Preview PDF