The Bombay High Court has set aside decree for possession in favour of T. S. Anklesaria, a Private Trust, holding that the plaintiffs failed to prove absolute title over Pune Cantonment land classified as Old Grant property and that the Union’s right of resumption remained protected. The Court held that General Land Register (GLR) entries and related documents showed the land was held on Old Grant terms, with the Government retaining proprietary rights and the plaintiffs enjoying only occupancy rights.
Relying on Union of India and Another vs. Dinshaw Shapoorji Anklesari [(2014) 14 SCC 204] and Chief Executive Officer vs. Surendra Kumar Vakil [(1999) 3 SCC 555], the Court ruled that the Union of India could not be treated as a tenant of Old Grant land and retained a right of resumption. The sale deed relied upon by the plaintiffs did not establish the original source of title to the land. Mere references to ownership in the sale deed were insufficient to displace Old Grant records.
The notice issued under Sections 106 and 111 of the Transfer of Property Act could not sustain a possession claim because the lease itself required six months’ notice and preserved the Government’s right of resumption. Hence, the High Court overturned the decree directing delivery of possession to the plaintiffs but left open any independent rights they may have concerning the bungalow structure under the lease arrangements.
Briefly, the dispute concerned a bungalow and land measuring about 0.85 acres situated in Pune Cantonment. The property was claimed by the respondents/plaintiffs, namely T. S. Anklesaria, a Private Trust and its trustees, as their absolute property. The Union of India and the Military Estate Officer had been occupying the property under lease arrangements since 1929, with the last lease being a ‘Repairing Lease’ executed in 1940.
After the lease period expired, the Union continued in possession. In 1972, the Union issued a resumption notice claiming that the land was held on Old Grant terms and offered compensation for the structure. The plaintiffs challenged that notice and later filed a civil suit seeking possession, arrears of rent, and damages, alleging that the Union had denied their title and forfeited its tenancy rights.
Also read Delhi High Court Grants Bail To Man Accused Of Marrying Woman Using Forged Divorce Decree
A Single Judge Bench of Justice Gauri Godse found that while the original 1929 lease appeared to have been executed under the provisions of the Cantonments (House Accommodation) Act, the subsequent agreements, including the 1940 Repairing Lease, appeared to be private agreements. The Court further noted that the Bombay Rent Act had been extended to cantonment areas but specifically excluded tenancies created by Government grants or premises taken on lease by the Government in cantonment areas. Therefore, the Rent Act did not govern the present dispute.
On the issue of title, the Court examined the General Land Register (GLR), Old Grant records, Government General Order of 1827, lease documents, and additional evidence. The GLR classified the land as Class B-3 land and recorded the plaintiffs only as holders of occupancy rights under Old Grant terms. The Court held that the plaintiffs failed to produce any valid title document establishing absolute ownership of the land. The sale deed relied upon by them merely transferred whatever rights the vendor possessed and did not establish ownership of the land itself. The documentary record consistently showed that the Government had retained proprietary rights in the soil and that only occupancy rights had been granted.
The Court further observed that the lease agreements expressly preserved the Government’s right of resumption. Since the Union could not be treated as an ordinary tenant and its right of resumption was protected under the contractual documents and Old Grant regime, the plaintiffs could not terminate possession by issuing a notice under Sections 106 and 111 of the Transfer of Property Act.
Appearances
Mr. Atul Damle, Senior Advocate a/w. Mr. Rui Rodrigues, Ms. Payal Vardhan and Mr. Jainendra Sheth for the Appellants.
Mr. R. D. Soni a/w. Mr. Sandeep Parikh, Ms. Dhanashree Gaikaiwari and Mr. Ayaz Bilawala i/b. M/s. Bilawala & Co. for Respondents.

