loader image

Supreme Court Disposes of A.K. Antony’s Plea Against ECI’s SIR Exercise

Supreme Court Disposes of A.K. Antony’s Plea Against ECI’s SIR Exercise

A.K. Antony v. Election Commission of India & Ors., W.P. (C) No. 1429/2026 [Order dated November 19, 2026]

Supreme Court SIR

The Supreme Court on Thursday disposed of a petition filed by A.K. Antony challenging the Election Commission of India’s approach to the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls. During the hearing, the Bench questioned the petitioner over the specific relief sought and asked him to identify any personal grievance arising from the exercise.

Appearing in person, AK Antony argued that the Election Commission had acted contrary to the objectives of the SIR exercise and the Supreme Court’s order dated June 24, 2025. He submitted that the exercise was intended to focus on shifted electors and prepare an updated electoral roll through fresh house-to-house enumeration.

He contended that instead of identifying eligible voters at their current places of residence, the ECI had relied on the existing electoral roll and provided enumeration forms only at voters’ previously recorded addresses. This, he argued, defeated the purpose of the exercise and could leave out people who had shifted residence, particularly those living in slums and informal settlements without formally numbered houses. He submitted that the process had effectively compelled several shifted voters to return to their old addresses out of fear of being excluded from the electoral roll.

“

“The shifted electors were the focus. The existing electoral roll is incorrect and inaccurate, and the aim was to remove the shifted electors and also to make a complete electoral roll during the SIR. But what has been done is that the shifted electors were removed from the existing place and they were given enumeration forms only at the same address,” he submitted.

He further argued that the stated objective was to ensure that every eligible elector was captured wherever they were residing, and that house-to-house enumeration was necessary to achieve this. Referring to people without formal addresses, he said that thousands of families lived in huts and slum areas and could be left out if the existing electoral roll continued to serve as the basis for enumeration.

The petitioner also referred to a detailed representation submitted in the first week of January, which he said was placed at page 90 of the petition. He stated that the representation had been addressed to the Chief Electoral Officers of Kerala and Tamil Nadu and forwarded to the Election Commission.

The Bench, however, repeatedly sought clarity on the specific grievance and relief being sought. He responded that his daughter had been included in the electoral roll, despite his concerns about the manner in which the enumeration forms were collected. When the Bench asked, “Your daughter has been included in the roll? What is the problem, sir?”, he said that people had enrolled themselves at incorrect addresses out of fear of being excluded.

The Bench observed that a correction mechanism was available and that the Election Commission had issued subsequent communications to address the situation. It told the petitioner that individual grievances should be raised through the appropriate process, observing that he was making “omnibus allegations”.

The Court ultimately disposed of the petition.