Quashing Gangsters Act FIR against liquor company officials and an excise officer, the Allahabad High Court has held that economic offences already under trial cannot automatically be treated as gang activity, and mechanical approval of a gang chart without independent application of mind vitiates proceedings. Essentially, the High Court has quashed a Gangsters Act FIR registered by the Saharanpur Police in connection with the 2021 country liquor excise evasion case.
The High Court held that excise-duty evasion, cheating and forgery allegations may constitute ordinary criminal offences, but the Gangsters Act can be invoked only when the statutory ingredients of a ‘gang’ under Section 2(b) of the Uttar Pradesh Gangsters and Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act, 1986 and Rule 3 of the Uttar Pradesh Gangsters and Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Rules, 2021 are satisfied. The record did not disclose any act of violence, threat, public intimidation or coercion by the petitioners. Therefore, the allegations failed to establish organised gang activity contemplated by the Act.
The alleged liquor-duty evasion incident occurred in March 2021, whereas the gang chart and FIR under the Act were prepared in December 2025. The Court found no material showing continuing gang activity warranting invocation of the Act nearly five years later. The Court found that the approving authorities merely reproduced identical endorsements, failed to record meaningful reasons, produced no proper minutes of the mandatory joint meeting, and did not individually assess the role of each accused. Such mechanical approval was held legally unsustainable.
Since the Supreme Court did not strike down the legislation or decide its constitutional validity, the Act continues to remain in force. However, its provisions must be invoked strictly in accordance with statutory safeguards, added the High Court.
Briefly, the case arose from a liquor-duty evasion case relating to a country liquor manufacturing unit at Saharanpur. On 3 March 2021, Excise Department and STF officials intercepted a truck allegedly carrying liquor on a second trip using the same transport pass and barcode, resulting in allegations of excise duty evasion, cheating, forgery and manipulation of records. Several FIRs were registered and, after investigate on by the SIT, ten charge-sheets were filed against various accused, including Pranay Aneja, Ashwani Upadhyay, Upendra Govind Rao and Ravindra Kishor. Cognizance had already been taken, and the criminal trial was pending before the Special Court at Lucknow. All the petitioners had been granted bail in the base case.
In December 2025, nearly four years and nine months after the alleged incident, a gang chart was prepared and approved under the Uttar Pradesh Gangsters and Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act, 1986. Relying solely on the 2021 excise-duty evasion case as the base case, the authorities registered an FIR against twenty-seven persons, alleging that they constituted a gang involved in illegal activities for unlawful gain. The petitioners challenged the Gangsters Act FIR, the gang chart and all consequential proceedings.
The Division Bench comprising Justice Chandra Dhari Singh and Justice Tarun Saxena observed that although the Supreme Court in Shiv Pratap Singh had expressed serious doubts about the scheme of the Gangsters Act and held that the Act creates no independent offence, it had not struck down the statute or declared it unconstitutional. Therefore, the Act continues to remain operative and binding until decided otherwise by a larger forum.
The Court found that the allegations in the base case essentially related to excise-duty evasion, forgery and cheating, which were already the subject matter of pending criminal prosecution. However, the materials on record did not disclose any violence, threat, intimidation, coercion, disturbance of public order, or any conduct satisfying the essential ingredients of ‘gang’ under Section 2(b) of the Gangsters Act read with Rule 3 of the 2021 Rules. The Court held that merely because persons are co-accused in an economic offence does not automatically make them members of a gang.
The Bench further noted that the alleged incident occurred in March 2021, the manufacturing unit had remained sealed thereafter, and no further activity falling within the Gangsters Act was attributed to any petitioner. In these circumstances, the Court found no rational basis for invoking the Gangsters Act almost five years later when the original prosecution was already progressing before the competent court.
The Court also expressed serious concern regarding the preparation and approval of the gang chart. It found that the authorities failed to demonstrate independent application of mind, as required by Rules 5(3)(a), 16 and 17 of the 2021 Rules. The endorsements at different levels were virtually identical, several of them were undated, no meaningful minutes of the mandatory joint meeting were produced, and there was no individual assessment of each accused person’s role. The Court held that such mechanical approvals amounted to a mere rubber-stamping exercise rather than a lawful satisfaction required before invoking the exceptional provisions of the Gangsters Act.
The Bench further observed that laws carrying harsher consequences than ordinary criminal law must be invoked with restraint. When a regular criminal case has already been investigated, charge-sheeted, and is pending trial, authorities must specifically justify why ordinary criminal law is inadequate before resorting to the Gangsters Act.
Appearances
Counsel for Petitioners: Atul Khaneja, Subir Lal, Sr. Advocate, Ram Prakash
Counsel for Respondents: G.A.

