Holding that prosecution of a Central Government officer without prior sanction strikes at the court’s jurisdiction, the Bombay High Court has set aside ED complaint and cognizance order set aside for non-compliance with Section 197 CrPC. The Court held that where a public servant is protected under Section 197 CrPC, a court cannot take cognizance of the offence without prior sanction from the competent government authority.
The record showed that the ED had proceeded with the complaint and cognizance was taken despite the absence of a valid sanction for prosecution. Before taking cognizance, the Special PMLA Court ought to have ascertained whether mandatory sanction had been obtained from the competent authority, added the Court.
Since the allegations concerned accumulation of wealth while the petitioner was serving as a public servant, the Court found that the protection under Section 197 required consideration and prior sanction was necessary before prosecution could proceed. Accordingly, the Court ruled that absence of prior sanction is not a mere procedural irregularity but a foundational defect going to the root of the proceedings, rendering the prosecution legally unsustainable.
Briefly, the petitioner, Sachin Sawant, a Joint Commissioner of Customs and an Indian Revenue Service officer, challenged the Special PMLA Court’s order dated 31 August 2023 taking cognizance of an Enforcement Directorate (ED) complaint alleging money laundering under Sections 3 and 4 of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 (PMLA). The case originated from a CBI FIR alleging that he had amassed assets disproportionate to his known sources of income and had allegedly routed funds through accounts of associates and family members. The predicate corruption case remained under investigation, and no final report had been filed.
The petitioner contended that, being a Central Government public servant who could not be removed without the Central Government’s sanction, prosecution could not have been launched without obtaining prior sanction under Section 197(1)(a) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973. According to him, the absence of such sanction rendered the complaint and cognizance order illegal.
The ED argued that sanction under Section 197 CrPC was unnecessary because the allegations related to acquisition, possession, concealment, layering and projection of alleged proceeds of crime, which were personal acts unconnected with the discharge of official duties. Therefore, the protection under Section 197 CrPC was not attracted.
Also read Supreme Court Dismisses ED’s Challenge To Azam Khan’s Interim Bail
A Single Judge Bench of Justice Milind N. Jadhav noted that the ED itself admitted that cognizance had been taken without obtaining a valid sanction from the competent authority. The Court found that although the ED claimed sanction was unnecessary, it had not adequately explained how the alleged accumulation of disproportionate assets was completely detached from the petitioner’s status and functioning as a public servant.
The Court observed that Section 197 CrPC creates a statutory bar on courts taking cognizance against a protected public servant without prior sanction where the alleged acts bear a reasonable nexus with official duties. It also held that the allegations against the petitioner related to amassing wealth while serving in public office and, therefore, the case attracted the requirement of prior sanction. In such circumstances, sanction was a sine qua non for institution of prosecution and taking cognizance.
The Court further observed that before taking cognizance, the Special Court was required to ascertain whether statutory sanction had been obtained. Since the petitioner was admittedly a public servant not removable without Central Government approval, the Special Court ought to have examined this prerequisite before proceeding with the complaint.
Appearances
Mr. Mithilesh Mishra a/w Mr. Hrituraj Singh, Ms. Namasvi Bhanushali, Mr. Pradeep Dubey, Mr. Rushan Balsara, Ms. Dnyaneshwari Hadawale, Advocates for Petitioner.
Mr. Prashant Mishra, Special Counsel a/w Ms. Purva Birla, Ms. Shruti Chande, Mr. Bharat Jadhav, Mr. Krish Kariya, Mr. Akshun Thakur, Ms. Tisha Thakkar, Mr. Ketan Gavhane, Advocates for Respondent No.1 – ED.
Ms. Anuja S. Gotad, APP for Respondent No.2 – State.

