loader image

Market Rent Admission by Tenant Can Determine Mesne Profits; SC Reiterates That Interest Is Integral Component Of Compensation For Wrongful Occupation Of Property

Market Rent Admission by Tenant Can Determine Mesne Profits; SC Reiterates That Interest Is Integral Component Of Compensation For Wrongful Occupation Of Property

Bharat Bhushan Jain (Dead) Through LRs vs Goodyear India [Decided on November 18, 2026]

Mesne Profits and Market Rent

While upholding mesne profits fixed on the basis of tenant’s own evidence, the Supreme Court has reiterated that mesne profits are intended to compensate the landlord for loss suffered due to continued unauthorized occupation after termination of tenancy. The Apex Court upheld the Delhi High Court’s finding that the First Appellate Court had overlooked a crucial admission by the tenant’s own witness that prevailing rent in the locality ranged between Rs. 5 and Rs. 8 per sq. ft. per month.

The Apex Court agreed that rent received from premises leased to Vijaya Bank could not be directly relied upon because the properties differed in age, construction, usage, and layout. The Court also fixing mesne profits at Rs. 7 per sq. ft. per month for the ground floor and Rs. 5 per sq. ft. per month for the mezzanine floor was held to be a balanced determination supported by evidence on record.

The Supreme Court affirmed that interest is an integral component of mesne profits as it compensates the owner for being deprived of beneficial enjoyment of the property during wrongful occupation.

Also read Retired Engineer’s Entire Pension Cannot Be Forfeited on Unproved Charges; Allahabad High Court Quashes Punishment Order And Upholds Restoration of Benefits

Briefly, the dispute arose from a landlord-tenant relationship concerning commercial premises at Ansari Road, Daryaganj, New Delhi, owned by the legal representatives of late Bharat Bhushan Jain (Dead) Through LRs. and leased to M/s Goodyear India Ltd. The landlords terminated the tenancy with effect from 31 December 1989 and filed a suit seeking possession of the premises along with damages for continued occupation after termination. While the decree for possession attained finality up to the Supreme Court in 2001, the issue of determining mesne profits (compensation for wrongful occupation after termination of tenancy) remained pending and continued through multiple rounds of litigation.

The Trial Court later fixed mesne profits at Rs. 22 per sq. ft. per month for the ground floor and Rs. 11 per sq. ft. per month for the mezzanine floor with 15% interest. However, the First Appellate Court set aside that determination, holding that it was based on speculative evidence and unsupported comparisons. The High Court subsequently modified the appellate decision and fixed mesne profits at Rs. 7 per sq. ft. per month for the ground floor and Rs. 5 per sq. ft. per month for the mezzanine floor, with simple interest at 7.5% per annum. The landlords approached the Supreme Court seeking enhancement of mesne profits and interest.

Also read Bail Does Not Legalise Stay in India Without Valid Visa; Delhi HC Rules Foreign Nationals Cannot be Restricted to Detention Centres as Bail Condition

A Two-Judge Bench comprising Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra and Justice N.V. Anjaria observed that mesne profits are compensatory in nature and are meant to compensate the true owner for loss caused by the wrongful occupation of property after termination of tenancy. The Court emphasized that there is no rigid formula for determining mesne profits and that courts must arrive at a fair and reasonable figure after considering the property’s location, nature, prevailing rental rates, evidence on record, and surrounding circumstances.

The Court noted that the Trial Court had heavily relied on the rent paid for another property occupied by Vijaya Bank. However, the First Appellate Court rightly found that the two properties were not genuinely comparable because they differed in age, construction, usage, and configuration. Therefore, the Vijaya Bank property could not be treated as a reliable benchmark for assessing mesne profits.

The Supreme Court further observed that the High Court correctly identified a significant error committed by the First Appellate Court. The appellate court had ignored an important admission made by the tenant’s own witness, who acknowledged that prevailing rents in the locality at the relevant time ranged between ₹5 and ₹8 per sq. ft. per month. According to the Court, overlooking such material evidence justified interference by the High Court in second appeal.

Also read Videocon Loan Case: Bombay High Court Sets Aside ICICI Bank’s Sanction To Prosecute Former CEO Chanda Kochhar

The Court held that the High Court did not blindly rely on the witness’s admission. Instead, it considered the entire evidence on record and arrived at a balanced determination of Rs. 7 per sq. ft. and Rs. 5 per sq. ft. for the respective portions of the premises. These figures fell within the evidentiary range disclosed by the tenant itself and could not be described as arbitrary or without evidence.

Regarding interest, the Supreme Court reiterated that interest forms an integral part of mesne profits because it compensates the owner for being deprived of the beneficial use of the property during the period of wrongful occupation. Therefore, the High Court’s award of 7.5% simple interest, reducible to 6% upon timely payment, was found to be reasonable.

The Court also highlighted that the litigation had its roots in a tenancy terminated in 1989 and that the dispute over mesne profits alone had continued for more than three decades. Since the High Court’s assessment was legally sound and based on evidence, the Supreme Court found it appropriate to bring finality to the long-pending dispute.

Appearances

For Appellants: Mr. Abhay Kumar- 1572, AOR, Mr. Shagun Ruhil, Adv., Mr. Shreenivash, Adv., Mr. Karan Chopra, Adv., Ms. Sakshi Sharma, Adv.

For Respondents: Mr. Prashanto Chandra Sen, Sr. Adv., Mr. Nihit Nagpal, Adv., Ms. Livya P. Lalu, Adv., M/s S. S. Rana & Co.- 428, AOR, Mrs. Bindra Rana, Aor, Adv., Mr. Vikrant Rana, Aor, Adv., Ms. Abha R. Sharma- 1049, AOR

PDF Icon

Bharat Bhushan Jain (Dead) Through LRs vs Goodyear India

Preview PDF