The Metropolitan Magistrate-04, South District, Saket Court, New Delhi, referred three questions of law in a criminal reference before the Delhi High Court under Section 395(2) read with Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (CrPC), being heard by a Division Bench of Justice Navin Chawla and Justice Arun Bhardwaj.
The first question was whether granting unconditional bail to a foreign national accused of overstaying would legalise his future stay without a valid visa, and whether a bail order could substitute for a visa. Second, whether cases of foreign nationals accused under Section 14 of the Foreigners Act, 1946, especially where the accused concedes that the visa had expired, should be treated differently from other criminal cases. Third, whether conditions, including keeping the accused in a detention centre until the trial ended, could be imposed on a foreign national granted bail.
The Metropolitan Magistrate was hearing the bail application of a Nigerian national accused under Section 14 of the Foreigners Act, 1946. The accused had come to India in 2016 on a three-month tourist visa and continued to live in the country after the visa expired. He argued that he was entitled to bail and that he would apply for a visa extension once released. On the other hand, the State argued that a foreign national granted bail should be kept in a detention centre. Hence, the present reference was listed before the Court.
The Court noted three developments since the reference was made. First, the Immigration and Foreigners Act, 2025 repealed the 1946 Act. Section 23 of the new Act became the corresponding penal provision, and Section 25 allowed certain offences to be compounded. The Immigration and Foreigners Order, 2025 replaced the earlier orders, and Paragraph 8(2) required States to set up holding centres for restricting the movement of foreigners until deportation. Second, the Ministry of Home Affairs issued an SOP dated 10-12-2025 for processing visas of foreign nationals in criminal cases who were granted bail. It was also noted that affidavit of the Foreigners Regional Registration Office (FRRO) dated 17-07-2026 clarified that persons prosecuted under Section 14 of the 1946 Act or Section 23 of the 2025 Act were not eligible for an X-Misc. visa, and that such persons could instead compound the offence under Section 25. Third, the Court noted that later judgments had held that courts could not direct detention-centre confinement as a bail condition. The Court noted that detention was an executive power of the Central Government.
ALSO READ: IBC Cannot Be Used To Escape Binding BIFR Rehabilitation Scheme: Rules Supreme Court
The Court held that a foreign national accused under Section 14 of the 1946 Act, or Section 23 of the 2025 Act, was being tried for a contravention committed in the past. It was stated that for enforcing provisions of Section 14 or Section14A of the 1946 Act for the future, it is for the central government to adopt different options given under Section 3 of the Foreigners Order, 1948, and adopt different measures for different persons, such a requiring the person to reside at a particular place or imposing other restrictions on movement within India. Hence, the Court stated that granting bail to such a foreign national does not, by itself, tantamount to legalising his continued stay in India or operate as a substitute for a valid visa.
The Court’s answer to the second question was in the negative. It held that such accused persons were to be dealt with like any other accused and could be released on bail subject to appropriate conditions, but not a condition of detention in a detention centre during the trial. The Court also noted that Section 25 of the 2025 Act had a provision for compounding of certain offences upon payment of a penalty, and that the SOP provided for deportation and blacklisting of those unable to pay. It stated that once these options are exercised, there might be no need to grant bail at all.
On question 3, the Court held that bail could be granted to a foreign national on reasonable conditions regarding place of residence, restriction on movement, and periodic reporting, having regard to the gravity of the offence and the risk of evading trial. However, the Court stated that a condition confining the foreign national to a detention centre would frustrate the very order of bail and could not be imposed. It was held that such a power belonged to the central government under Section 3(2)(g) of the 1946 Act or Paragraph 8 of the Immigration and Foreigners Order, 2025.
Thus, the reference was answered accordingly and disposed of.
Appearances
For Petitioner – Mr. Harsh Prabhakar (Amicus Curiae), Ms. Pallavi Garg, Mr. Yash Kotak, Mr. Dhruv Chaudhry, Mr. Shubham Sourav, Mr. Vijit Singh
For Respondents – Mr. Aman Usman (APP), Mr. Manvendra Yadav for State
Mr. Amit Tiwari (CGSC), Ms. Ayushi Srivastava, Mr. Arpan Narwal, Mr. Kushagra Malik, Mr. Ujjwal Tyagi

