While quashing additional demand and land-use conditions, the Supreme Court has ruled that once the 2004 exchange allotment failed due to the Housing Board’s own lapse, restrictions attached to that allotment could not be imposed on the fresh 2016 exchange deed. The Court held that the 2004 exchange arrangement failed because M/s Gaursons India Pvt Ltd.’s predecessors were allotted land that had already been reserved for a bird sanctuary and was encumbered by legal restrictions. The fault lay with the Uttar Pradesh Avas Evam Vikas Parishad, which was therefore bound to provide a valid alternative allotment.
The Apex Court ruled that the 1995 compromise and the 2004 exchange deed imposed land-use restrictions only on the original acquired land and the failed 2004 allotment. Those conditions could not automatically bind the fresh residential land allotted under the 2016 exchange deed. Upholding the 2005 sale deed, the Court held that the original owners were entitled to transfer not only the allotted land but also the right to receive any substitute land that might later be granted by the Housing Board.
The Court found that the Housing Board had already retained, developed and monetised the original acquired land, which carried higher value than the land exchanged in 2016. Having also accepted substantial conversion charges, the Board could not subsequently demand current bulk-sale rates from the developer. While allegations of collusion between officials and the developer were raised on the basis of an SIT report, the Supreme Court expressly refrained from ruling on those findings and left it open to competent authorities to proceed in accordance with law.
Briefly, the dispute arose from land acquired by Uttar Pradesh Avas Evam Vikas Parishad vs Gaursons India concerning 12.047 acres of land originally owned by the predecessors of M/s Gaursons India Pvt Ltd. under the Vasundhara Scheme in Ghaziabad. After the acquisition was challenged, the parties entered into a compromise before the Supreme Court in 1995 under which the acquired land was to be adjusted in the scheme, and an exchange deed was to be executed without payment of compensation by either side.
Pursuant to the compromise, the Housing Board executed an exchange deed in 2004 and allotted Khasra Nos. 948 and 1454 in Arthala village. However, it later surfaced that these lands had already been reserved for a bird sanctuary and one of the plots was recorded as a lake in revenue records. Since the allotted land could not be effectively enjoyed by the allottees, prolonged litigation followed. Eventually, in 2016, the Housing Board allotted an alternative residential parcel in the Siddharth Vihar Scheme through a fresh exchange deed, after which M/s Gaursons India Pvt Ltd. constructed residential units, including EWS/LIG houses, and created third-party rights in favour of homebuyers.
Subsequently, the Chief Secretary directed that the land already developed by Gaursons should be treated as a fresh allotment at prevailing bulk sale rates, resulting in a demand of about Rs. 388 crores. The Chief Secretary also sought to impose restrictions limiting the use of some land for water purification purposes. These directions were set aside by the Allahabad High Court.
A Two-Judge Bench comprising Justice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha and Justice Alok Aradhe observed that the 1995 compromise attached the condition relating to water purification activities only to the originally acquired land that was to be adjusted in the Vasundhara Scheme. The Court held that the compromise did not create a perpetual restriction that would automatically follow every future parcel of land allotted in exchange. Therefore, the condition could not be read as binding subsequent alternative allotments made years later.
The Court further noted that the Housing Board itself was responsible for the failure of the 2004 exchange arrangement because it allotted land which had already been resumed for a bird sanctuary and was burdened with serious legal and factual defects. The Board had failed to undertake proper due diligence before making the allotment. Consequently, the 2004 exchange deed effectively failed, obligating the Housing Board to provide a valid alternative allotment.
On the validity of the 2005 sale deed executed in favour of Gaursons, the Court held that the predecessors-in-interest were lawful owners of the allotted land and were entitled to transfer it. The sale deed not only transferred the land but also assigned the right to receive any alternative land that might be allotted in its place. Therefore, Gaursons validly stepped into the shoes of the original owners and became entitled to the benefit of any replacement allotment.
The Court also observed that the 2016 exchange deed was a fresh and independent registered instrument concerning a different plot in a different residential scheme. Unlike the 2004 deed, it expressly treated the land as a residential freehold plot and permitted residential development. The parties consciously incorporated only the condition that no value or consideration would be payable for the exchange, while not carrying forward the earlier land-use restrictions. Hence, the old covenants could not be imported into the 2016 deed.
Regarding allegations of collusion based on the SIT report, the Supreme Court declined to express any opinion on the report or its findings. The Court left the issue open for the competent authorities to act in accordance with law independently of the dispute before it.
The Court further found no justification for the Rs. 388 crore demand. It noted that the original acquired land had already been retained, developed and monetised by the Housing Board, and third-party rights had been created over it. The Court also took note of the fact that the land surrendered by the original owners was of higher value than the land eventually allotted under the Siddharth Vihar Scheme and that Gaursons had already paid substantial conversion charges. In such circumstances, the Board could not demand any additional consideration contrary to the original compromise and the 2016 exchange deed.
Appearances
For Appellants: Mr. R. Venkataramani, Attorney General for India, Ms. Aishwarya Bhati, A.S.G., Mr. Rana Mukherjee, Sr. Adv., Mr. Kamlendra Mishra- 1367, AOR, Mr. Rajeev Kumar Dubey, Adv., Mr. Ruchir Ranjan Rai, Adv., Mr. Ashiwan Mishra, Adv., Ms. Vaidruti Mishra, Adv., Ms. Aditi Mishra, Adv.
Mr. P. N. Misra, Sr. Adv., Mr. Abhishek Kumar Singh, AOR, Mr. Abhinav Jaganathan, Adv., Ms. Anamika Yadav, Adv., Mr. Harsh V. Singh, Adv., Mr. Kartik Arora, Adv., Ms. Pallavi Singh, Adv.
For Respondents: Ms. Veenu Singhal, Adv., Mr. Anand Shankar Jha- 2476, AOR, Mr. Divyanshu, Adv., Mr. Shubhank Sharma, Adv.
Mr. Kamlendra Mishra- 1367, AOR, Mr. Abhishek Kumar Singh- 2821, AOR

