Ruling that payment through redeemable NCDs violates Section 30(2)(b) of the IBC, the Supreme Court has affirmed NCLAT’s power to remit defective resolution plans to the CoC and held that offshore assets held by subsidiaries cannot be treated as assets of the parent company. The Court clarified that dissenting financial creditors cannot be forced to accept payment through long-term non-convertible debentures (NCDs). The requirement under Section 30(2)(b) of the IBC contemplates actual monetary payment and not deferred payment instruments redeemable over several years.
While the NCLT rightly identified the defect concerning payment to dissenting creditors, it exceeded its jurisdiction by directing upfront cash payments and effectively modifying the commercial terms of the resolution plan. Any such modification must be considered by the CoC, not the adjudicating authority. The Court affirmed that the NCLAT possesses the power to remit a non-compliant resolution plan to the Committee of Creditors. Remand is the appropriate remedy where legal defects exist but can be cured without pushing the corporate debtor into liquidation.
The Apex Court also said that Committee of Creditors continues to exist until the resolution process reaches finality through implementation or liquidation. Therefore, the CoC can revisit an approved plan when its legality is under challenge and the plan is set aside on statutory grounds. Rejecting the promoter’s challenge, the Court held that foreign oil and gas assets held through overseas subsidiaries of Videocon Industries Limited remain assets of those subsidiaries. Section 18 of the IBC expressly excludes assets of Indian and foreign subsidiaries from the insolvency estate of the parent company.
Briefly, the case arose from the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP) of Videocon Industries Limited (VIL) and twelve other group companies. The Committee of Creditors (CoC) approved the resolution plan submitted by Twinstar Technologies Limited with a 95.09% voting share. The plan contemplated a total payout of about Rs. 2,962 crores against admitted claims exceeding Rs. 64,000 crores. Certain financial creditors, including Bank of Maharashtra, IFCI Ltd. and SIDBI, dissented and challenged the plan primarily on the ground that they were to be paid through long-term non-convertible debentures (NCDs) rather than cash, allegedly violating Section 30(2)(b) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC).
The NCLT approved the plan after directing that dissenting creditors be paid upfront in cash, but the NCLAT later set aside the approval and remitted the matter back to the CoC. A connected dispute concerned valuable foreign oil and gas assets held through overseas subsidiaries of the Videocon group. The promoter, Venugopal Dhoot, argued that these assets should be included in the CIRP of Videocon Industries Limited to increase recoveries for creditors.
A Two-Judge Bench comprising Justice Alok Aradhe and Justice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha reiterated that the IBC gives primacy to the commercial wisdom of the CoC. However, courts and tribunals are duty-bound to ensure that a resolution plan complies with mandatory provisions of the Code. While the NCLT and NCLAT cannot rewrite or modify a commercial resolution plan, they are empowered to test its legality and statutory compliance.
The Court observed that payment to dissenting financial creditors under Section 30(2)(b) must be actual payment in money. A dissenting creditor cannot be compelled to remain invested in the company through securities, debentures, or similar instruments. Since the Twinstar plan effectively proposed payment to dissenting creditors through NCDs redeemable over several years, it did not satisfy the statutory requirement.
The Court further held that a mere statement in a resolution plan that the plan complies with the law is not enough. The plan itself must clearly specify how dissenting creditors will receive the amounts guaranteed to them under the IBC.
On the NCLT’s direction requiring upfront cash payment to dissenting creditors, the Court held that the NCLT had impermissibly altered the payment structure of the plan. Such modification falls exclusively within the commercial domain of the CoC and cannot be carried out by the adjudicating authority.
The Court also clarified that the CoC does not become functus officio (powerless) immediately after approving a resolution plan. The CoC continues to exist until the plan is implemented or the process otherwise attains finality. Therefore, where a plan is set aside on legal grounds, the CoC can reconsider the matter.
Regarding the foreign oil and gas assets, the Court held that assets owned by Indian or foreign subsidiaries are expressly excluded from the assets of the corporate debtor under Section 18 of the IBC. Even if a holding company indirectly controls a subsidiary, it does not legally own the subsidiary’s assets. The promoter’s attempt to include those foreign assets in VIL’s CIRP was therefore rejected.
Appearances
For Appellant(s): Mr. Diwakar Maheshwari, Adv.; Mr. Shreyas Edupuganti, Adv.; Ms. Pratiksha Mishra, Adv.; Mr. Shubham Saini, Adv.; Ms. Bhavika Deora, Adv.;Mr. Karun Mehta, AOR, Mr. Ritesh Kumar Chowdhary, AOR; Mr. Gaurav Singh, Adv., Mr. Sandeep S. Ladda, Adv.; Mrs. Prabhleen Apoorv Shukla, AOR, Mr. Soumik Ghosal, AOR; Mr. Karun Mehta, AOR
For Respondent(s): Mr. Badri Prasad Singh, AOR; Mr. Abhishek Singh, Adv., Mr. S. S. Shroff, AOR; Mr. Anoop Rawat, Adv.; Mr. Vaijayant Paliwal, Adv.; Mr. Vishrut Kansal, Adv.; Ms. Moulshree Shukla, Adv.; Ms. Gayathri Balasubramanian, Adv., Mr. Tushar Mehta, Solicitor General; Mr. Madhav Kanoria, Adv.; Ms. Surabhi Khattar, Adv.; Ms. Srideepa Bhattacharyya, Adv.; Ms. Neha Shivhare, Adv.; Mr. Shivansh Vishwakarma, Adv.; Ms. Pallavi Agrawal, Adv.; Mr. Vikash Kumar Jha, Adv., Mr. Shubhanshu Gupta, AOR, Mr. Sumant Nayak, Adv.; r. Aslam Ahmed Jamal, AOR; Mr. Rohit Jain, Adv.; Ms. Shraddha Chaudhari, Adv.; Ms. Smriti Shukla, Adv.; Ms. Ankita Sharma, Adv.; Mr. Abhishek Dwivedi, Adv.; Ms. Shaila Arora, Adv.; Ms. Divyansha, Adv., Mr. Zeeshan Haider, Adv., Mr. K.K. Venugopal, Sr. Adv.; Mr. Sandeep S. Ladda, Adv.; Mr. Soumik Ghosal, AOR; Ms. Chinmayee Chandra, Adv.; Ms. Rohini Srinivasan, Adv.; Mr. Ashutosh Chaturvedi, Adv., Mr. Gaurav Singh, Adv.; Mr. Ritesh Kumar Chowdhary- 2270, AOR, Mr. K. R. Sasiprabhu, AOR, Mr. N Venkatraman, A.S.G.; Ms. Anindita Roychowdhury, Adv.; Ms. Vatsala Rai, Adv.; Mr. Abhijnan Jha, AOR, Mr. Soumik Ghosal, AOR, Mr. Abhinav Agrawal, AOR; Mr. Piyush Bhardwaj, Adv.; Mr. Shivam Sengupta, Adv., Mr. Tanuj Sud, Adv.; Mr. Ajay Kumar, Adv.; Ms. Stuti Vatsa, Adv., Mr. Vijayant Goel, Adv.; Mr. Abhikalp Pratap Singh, AOR, Mr. S. S. Shroff, AOR; Mr. Anoop Rawat, Adv.; Mr. Vaijayant Paliwal, Adv.; Ms. Moulshree Shukla, Adv.; Ms. Gayathri Balasubramanian, Adv.; Mr. Vishrut Kansal, Adv., Mr. Karun Mehta, AOR, Mr. T. Sundar Ramanathan, AOR; Mr. Krishan Singhal, Adv.; Ms. Aastha Sardana, Adv., Ms. Varuna Bhanrale, Adv.; Ms. Ananya Sinha, Adv.; Mr. Shahid Khan, Adv., Mr. Tushar Mehta, Solicitor General; Mr. Madhav Kanoria, Adv.; Ms. Surabhi Khattar, Adv.; Ms. Srideepa Bhattacharyya, Adv.; Ms. Neha Shivhare, Adv.; Ms. Pallavi Agarwal, Adv.; Mr. Shivansh Vishwakarma, Adv.; Ms. Pallavi Agrawal, Adv.; Mr. Vikash Kumar Jha, Adv., Mr. N Venkatraman, A.S.G.; Ms. Anindita Roychowdhury, Adv.; Ms. Vatsala Rai, Adv.; Mr. Abhijnan Jha- 3209, AOR, Mr. Manoj K. Mishra, AOR; Mr. Umesh Dubey, Adv.; Mr. Amrendra Kumar Singh, Adv.; Mr. Amulya Dev Mishra, Adv.; Ms. Shriji Mishra, Adv.; Mr. Shashank Tiwari, Adv.; Mr. Sarthak Tiwari, Adv., Mr. Piyush Joshi, Adv.; Ms. Sumiti Yadava, Adv.; Ms. Vatsla Bhatia, Adv.; Ms. Aarshia Biju Shantharam, Adv.; Ms. Sonakshi Malhan, AOR, Mr. Pukhrambam Ramesh Kumar, AOR; Mr. Soumik Ghosal- 2373, AOR, Mr. Tushar Mehta, Solicitor General; Mr. Madhav Kanoria, Adv.; Ms. Surabhi Khattar, Adv.; Ms. Neha Shivhare, Adv.; Mr. Shivansh Vishwakarma, Adv.; Ms. Pallavi Agarwal, Adv.; Ms. Pallavi Agrawal, Adv.; Mr. Vikash Kumar Jha, Adv., Mr. S. S. Shroff AOR, Mr. T. Sundar Ramanathan, AOR; Mr. Krishan Singhal, Adv.; Ms. Aastha Sardana, Adv.

