The Supreme Court heard submissions concerning the proposal to enhance the retirement age of judicial officers from 60 to 62 years, with several States indicating their willingness to implement the enhancement while others sought additional time to consider the proposal.
During the hearing, the Bench discussed concerns raised by States regarding the financial and administrative implications of the proposed extension. It was submitted that the enhancement would not entail any additional increase in pay and would instead allow judicial officers to continue serving until the age of 62, subject to the applicable framework.
The Court also considered the request by the States for imposing a compulsory suitability assessment as a condition for the extension. Counsel submitted that such an assessment should not be made mandatory for every judicial officer as has been dealt in Shetty Commission Report back in 1999 and considered by the Supreme Court thereafter.
Another issue concerned judicial officers who retired between March and September 2026 and were allegedly left without clarity regarding their pensionary benefits following the change in position taken by certain States. The Court was also requested to protect the consideration of retired judicial officers who may have been eligible for elevation to the High Courts.
The Bench sought a constructive proposal from the States yet to agree to the enhancement and indicated that the final directions should provide a definite timeline for implementation. The Counsel representing Himachal Pradesh informed the Court that its competent authority had considered the proposal, subject to certain conditions concerning pay fixation and calculation of pensionary benefits.

