The Allahabad High Court (Lucknow Bench) has ruled that the departmental inquiry findings must be backed by cogent evidence and reasoned analysis, and charges cannot be treated as proved merely because the employee failed to mount an effective defence. The Court found that the inquiry officer merely declared the charges proved without identifying the documents or evidence relied upon to substantiate the findings.
Even if a delinquent employee does not effectively contest the proceedings, the burden remains on the employer to establish the charges through reliable and cogent evidence. Before depriving a retired employee of pensionary benefits, the authority must clearly establish how the employee caused financial loss to the department and the extent of such loss. No such finding existed in the present case.
Briefly, an Assistant Engineer who joined the power department in 1985 and later served as Superintending Engineer at Noida, retired on 31 March 2021 with an otherwise clean service record. After his retirement, U.P. Power Corporation Ltd. through its Chairman, initiated disciplinary proceedings against him concerning five charges related to his tenure at Noida. An inquiry officer held all charges proved except one charge which was treated as partially proved.
Based on the inquiry report, the Corporation passed an order forfeiting 100% of his pension and retiral benefits. His departmental appeal was also dismissed, following which he approached the High Court through a writ petition. The Single Judge set aside the punishment and appellate orders and directed restoration of pension and payment of retiral dues with 6% interest, leading the Corporation to file the present intra-court appeal.
The Division Bench comprising the Chief Justice Arun Bhansali and Justice Jaspreet Singh found that the inquiry report merely stated that the charges were proved but failed to disclose what evidence was examined and how such evidence established the charges. The report did not indicate which documentary records were relied upon for proving individual charges. The Court held that findings recorded without discussing the supporting evidence are inherently vulnerable and cannot sustain serious punishment.
The Court particularly noted that Charge Nos. 3 and 4 were independent allegations, yet the inquiry officer appeared to rely on the partial proof of Charge No. 3 to conclude that Charge No. 4 was also proved. According to the Court, there was no proper evaluation of evidence for either charge, making the findings perverse and legally unsustainable. Similar deficiencies were found in relation to the other charges as well.
Rejecting the Corporation’s argument that the employee had not effectively denied the charges, the Court observed that even where a delinquent employee does not put forward a strong defence, the employer remains under a legal obligation to prove the charges through cogent and reliable evidence. Charges cannot be treated as proved merely because the employee’s defence is weak or inadequate.
The Court further emphasized that forfeiture of an employee’s entire pension is an extremely serious consequence and therefore requires strict proof of misconduct. Before imposing such punishment, the authority must clearly establish how the employee caused financial loss to the department and quantify that loss. In the present case, neither the inquiry report nor the punishment order contained any material showing that the respondent was responsible for any actual financial loss. The conclusions were based largely on estimates, assumptions and vague assertions rather than proven evidence.
The Bench also found that the disciplinary authority had mechanically reproduced the charges, the employee’s reply and the inquiry findings without demonstrating independent application of mind. Similarly, the appellate authority failed to consider the grounds raised in appeal and simply affirmed the punishment. Such decision-making could not be sustained in law.
Appearances
Counsel for Appellants: Mr. Manish Jauhari
Counsel for Respondents: Mr. Gaurav Mehrotra (Sr. Adv.) assisted by Mr. Akber Ahmad and Ms. Shhreiya Agarwal

