The Delhi High Court has ruled that a parent company supplies a taxable service by extending its creditworthiness to a related entity, but allows taxpayers to rebut the deemed 1% valuation by proving a lower open market value. The Court held that when a holding/group company provides a corporate guarantee for borrowings of its subsidiary or related entity, it supplies a taxable service by assuming the risk of default and extending its creditworthiness, even if no guarantee commission is charged.
The High Court ruled that the real beneficiary and recipient of the service is the related entity whose borrowing is supported, since it gains access to finance and improved credit terms through the guarantee. While upholding the constitutional validity of Rule 28(2) of the Central Goods and Services Tax Rules, 2017, the Court read it down and held that taxpayers can establish a lower open market value through cogent and verifiable evidence. The deemed 1% valuation cannot operate as an irrebuttable minimum.
The Court rejected arguments that corporate guarantees fall outside GST as actionable claims under Schedule III or as securities excluded from the definition of services. Guarantees executed before 1 July 2017 cannot be taxed merely because they continue to remain in force. GST liability arises only if such guarantees are renewed, extended, enhanced or otherwise modified after GST came into force.
Briefly, a batch of petitions were filed challenging the GST levy on corporate guarantees furnished by holding or group companies in favour of banks and financial institutions for loans availed by their subsidiaries or related entities. The petitioners contended that such guarantees are generally issued without charging any fee, are merely shareholder activities undertaken to protect investments, do not amount to a ‘supply of service’ under the GST law, and therefore cannot be taxed. They also challenged the validity of Rule 28(2) of the CGST Rules, 2017 and related notifications and circulars prescribing a deemed valuation of 1% per annum of the guaranteed amount for GST purposes.
The Union Government defended the levy by arguing that a corporate guarantee provides a real economic benefit to the subsidiary by allowing it to obtain credit based on the parent company’s financial strength. According to the Government, even if no consideration is charged, such transactions between related parties fall within Schedule I of the CGST Act and are taxable supplies.
Also read IBC Cannot Be Used To Escape Binding BIFR Rehabilitation Scheme: Rules Supreme Court
The Division Bench comprising Justice Anil Kshetarpal and Justice Bharat Parashar observed that a corporate guarantee is much more than a mere promise. By furnishing the guarantee, the parent company places its own creditworthiness, financial standing and borrowing capacity behind the subsidiary’s loan. The subsidiary derives a clear benefit because it obtains funding which it may otherwise not receive or would receive only on less favourable terms. Therefore, something of economic value flows from the guarantor to the subsidiary.
The Court held that the service lies in the assumption of financial risk and extension of credit support by the parent company. Such credit support is neither goods, nor money, nor securities and therefore falls within the wide definition of ‘services’ under the CGST Act. The fact that the guarantee is furnished to protect the parent’s investment does not change the character of the transaction. Motive cannot determine taxability when the transaction itself has the attributes of a supply.
The Court further held that the real recipient of the service is the subsidiary or related entity for whose benefit the guarantee is issued. Although the guarantee contract is executed in favour of the lender, the ultimate benefit of enhanced creditworthiness and access to finance accrues to the subsidiary.
On valuation, the Court accepted that the Government was justified in prescribing a deemed valuation mechanism because determining the market value of intra-group guarantees is difficult. However, it found that treating 1% per annum of the guaranteed amount as a mandatory and irrebuttable minimum value was arbitrary. The Court observed that in many cases the actual open market value could be lower and taxpayers must be allowed to prove such lower value through reliable material.
The Court also clarified that a corporate guarantee is not a continuous supply of service. The taxable event occurs when the guarantee is executed. Renewal, extension or enhancement of the guarantee constitutes a fresh taxable event, but the mere continued existence of an old guarantee does not create a new taxable supply every year.
Appearances
For Petitioners: Mr. Balbir Singh, Sr. Adv. with Mr. Kumar Visalaksh, Mr. Rahul Khurana, Mr. Udit Jain, Mr. Arihant Tater, Mr. Ajitesh Dayal Singh, Mr. Pranav Bansal, Mr. Vibhor Sharma, Ms. Disha Jham, Mr. Vedant Kohli and Mr. Karan Sachdev, Advs.
For Respondents: Ms. Tanvi Nigam, SPC for UOI.
Mr. Shashank Dixit, CGSC along with Mr. Kunal Raj, Adv., Mr. Shagun Shahi Chugh and Ms. Rimpy Rohilla, Advs.
Mr. N. Venkatraman, ASG with Mr. Atul Tripathi, SSC with Mr. Akshay Sagar, Mr. Shubham Mishra and Mr. Gaurav Mani Tripathi, Advs.

