loader image

Censure Or Withholding Of One Increment Within 7 Years Is Not Automatic Promotion Disqualification: Rajasthan High Court

Censure Or Withholding Of One Increment Within 7 Years Is Not Automatic Promotion Disqualification: Rajasthan High Court

State of Rajasthan vs Ajay Kant Ratudi [Decided on November 18, 2026]

Chief Justice Sanjay K. Agrawal, Justice Sameer Jain, and Justice Pramil Kumar Mathur

The Rajasthan High court (Jaipur Bench) has ruled that censure or withholding of one increment within seven years does not create an automatic bar to promotion under the seniority-cum-merit principle, and executive instructions cannot override statutory service rules. A government employee who has been awarded censure or stoppage of one grade increment without cumulative effect remains eligible to be considered for promotion unless the governing statutory rules expressly provide otherwise.

The Court held that departmental circulars prescribing a seven-year exclusion from promotion consideration cannot override or add to the disqualifications contained in the statutory service rules. While an employee does not possess a vested right to promotion, he does have a right to be considered for promotion in accordance with the applicable service rules. Excluding an employee from consideration solely based on a circular is impermissible.

Minor penalties remain relevant factors in assessing an employee’s suitability. The Departmental Promotion Committee is entitled to consider past misconduct and penalties while evaluating whether the employee meets the minimum standard required under the seniority-cum-merit criterion. The High Court also asserted that the existence of a minor penalty within the previous seven years cannot by itself justify denial of promotion. Suitability must be determined on a holistic assessment of the employee’s record and not merely because a circular mandates exclusion.

Also read Gangsters Act Cannot Be Invoked For Excise Duty Evasion Case Absent Proof Of Violence/ Organised Gang Activity: Allahabad HC Quashes FIR In Saharanpur Liquor Case

Briefly, the Full Bench was called upon to resolve a conflict in judicial opinions on whether a government employee who has been awarded minor penalties such as censure or stoppage of one grade increment without cumulative effect within the preceding seven years can be considered for promotion under the seniority-cum-merit criterion. The reference arose from the case of Ajay Kant Ratudi, a Police Inspector who had been awarded three censures in 2017, 2019 and 2021 and sought consideration for promotion to the Rajasthan Police Service despite those penalties.

The State relied upon Department of Personnel circulars dated July 26, 2006 and June 04, 2008, which were being interpreted to disentitle employees having certain minor penalties during the previous seven years from promotion consideration. The respondent contended that neither the Rajasthan Civil Services (Classification, Control & Appeal) Rules, 1958 nor the Rajasthan Police Service Rules, 1954 created any such statutory disqualification.

Also read Specific Performance Suit Does Not Abate Merely Because Settling Co-Defendants Die After Executing Conveyances: Bombay High Court

The Full Judge Bench comprising Chief Justice Sanjay K. Agrawal, Justice Sameer Jain, and Justice Pramil Kumar Mathur observed that Rule 14 of the Rajasthan Civil Services (Classification, Control & Appeal) Rules, 1958 treats censure and withholding of increments as minor penalties, while withholding of promotion is itself a separate and distinct penalty. The Rules do not prescribe that a person who has suffered censure or stoppage of increment becomes automatically ineligible for promotion for any specified period.

The Court emphasized that an executive circular cannot create a disqualification which the statutory rules themselves do not provide. Administrative instructions may supplement statutory rules where there is a gap, but they cannot amend, override or supplant those rules. Therefore, a circular cannot indirectly impose the effect of ‘withholding promotion’ upon an employee who has only been awarded a minor penalty such as censure.

Also read Delhi High Court Seeks ED, SFIO Response On Tina Ambani’s Plea Seeking Disclosure Of Look Out Circular

The Bench further noted that non-promotion is protected as not being a penalty only when the employee’s case has actually been considered and assessed for a post for which he is eligible. Excluding an employee from consideration altogether because of a circular would effectively amount to imposing the penalty of withholding promotion without following the statutory disciplinary procedure.

The Bench also clarified that promotion under the seniority-cum-merit principle is not automatic. Every eligible officer must satisfy the minimum standard of merit and suitability. A Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) is entitled to evaluate the employee’s entire service record, including disciplinary penalties, while assessing suitability. However, the presence of a minor penalty cannot by itself lead to automatic rejection from consideration.

Appearances

For Petitioners: Mr. Bhuwnesh Sharma, AAG with Mr. Samee Khan, Adv. and Mr. Vishnu Dutt Sharma, Adv., Mr. Siddharth Sharma, Adv., Ms. Epsa Nangalia, Adv., Mr. Banshi Lal Bhati, AAG through VC with Mr. Deepak Chandak, Adv., through VC and Ms. Sulochna Bishnoi, Adv., through VC, Mr. Sukhdev Sharma, Adv, through VC, Mr. N.S. Rajpurohit, AAG, through VC, with Ms. Aditi Sharma, Adv through VC, Mr. Sajjan Singh Rathore, AAG through VC

For Respondents: Mr. Ashish Saksena, Adv. with Mr. Akash Saxena, Adv. Mr. Banwari Lal Sharma, Adv. with Mr. Namo Narayan Sharma, Adv., Mr. Shobit Tiwari, Adv. with Mr. Pushpendra Singh, Adv. and Mr. Rohit Tiwari, Adv., Mr. Shiv Charan Gupta, Adv, Mr. Harsh Saraswat, Adv., Mr. Akshit Gupta, Adv., Ms. Pragya Seth, Adv., Mr. Naman Maheshwari, Adv., Mr. Vishwas Fatehpuria, Adv., Ms. Manasvita Sharma, Adv., Mr. G.S. Gouttam, Adv., Mr. Shreyansh Dhariwal, Adv., Mr. Nakul Bansal, Adv., Mr. Pallav Pancholi, Adv., Mr. Mohit Khandelwal, Adv., Mr. Pranav Sharma, Adv., Mr. Keshav Dadhich, Adv., Mr. Mohit Sharma, Adv., Ms. Parul Sharma, Adv., Mr. Naman Yadav, Adv., Mr. Yashpal Khileree, Adv., through VC, Ms. Vinita, Adv., through VC, Mr. Praveen Dayal Dave, Adv., through VC, Mr. Ankur Mathur, Adv., through VC

PDF Icon

State of Rajasthan vs Ajay Kant Ratudi

Preview PDF