The Kerala High Court (Ernakulam Bench) has ruled that consultation with the Registrar of Co-operative Societies cannot substitute the mandatory consultation with the State Government under the Banking Regulation Act. The Court however declines to restore the ousted board in view of public interest and the Administrator’s continued functioning.
The High Court held that the proviso to Section 36AAA(1) of the Banking Regulation Act expressly requires consultation with the concerned State Government and this requirement cannot be diluted. RBI’s consultation with the Registrar was held insufficient compliance with the statutory mandate because the Registrar and the State Government are distinct legal authorities under the cooperative law framework.
Reiterating settled principles of statutory interpretation, the Court observed that where a statute requires an act to be performed in a particular manner, it must be performed in that manner alone and not through an alternative administrative arrangement. The Court affirmed the view that members of the managing committee of a cooperative bank are not entitled to a personal hearing before RBI passes an order superseding the board under Section 36AAA.
Since the Administrator had already managed the bank for a considerable period and several administrative decisions had been taken, the Court refused to unsettle the existing arrangement on grounds of equity, depositor protection, and public interest.
Briefly, the dispute arose from the supersession of the elected Board of Directors of M P Jackson’s bank, the Irinjalakuda Town Co-operative Bank, by the Reserve Bank of India under Section 36AAA of the Banking Regulation Act, 1949. Earlier, RBI had imposed an All Inclusive Direction (AID) on the bank because of concerns regarding its functioning. While efforts were being made to improve the bank’s financial position by selling mortgaged assets, RBI issued an order dated Oct 07, 2025, superseding the elected board and appointing an Administrator. M P Jackson, the former President of the bank, challenged the order before the Kerala High Court.
Before the Single Judge, the petitioner argued that the supersession order was invalid because RBI had not consulted the State Government as required by the proviso to Section 36AAA(1) of the Banking Regulation Act. He also contended that the elected management was removed without being given an opportunity of hearing. The Single Judge held that consultation with the State Government was mandatory and had not been carried out, but declined to quash the order because the Administrator had already been functioning for several months and restoring the old management at that stage was considered contrary to public interest and depositor interests.
The Division Bench comprising Justice Anil K. Narendran and Justice Muralee Krishna S. noted that the proviso to Section 36AAA(1) expressly requires RBI to issue a supersession order “in consultation with the concerned State Government” where the cooperative bank is registered with a State Registrar. The Court emphasized that when a statute prescribes a specific procedure, that procedure alone must be followed and courts cannot add, delete, or substitute words in the legislation.
The Court rejected RBI’s argument that consultation with the Registrar of Co-operative Societies should be treated as consultation with the State Government. It observed that the Registrar and the Government are distinct authorities under the Kerala Co-operative Societies Act. Merely because the Registrar exercises important regulatory powers over cooperative societies does not mean that statutory consultation with the Government can be replaced by consultation with the Registrar.
The Bench further held that if Parliament intended consultation with the Registrar to be sufficient, it could have expressly said so. The Court cannot rewrite the statute to accommodate an administrative convenience or a perceived legislative intention. Therefore, the consultation requirement under Section 36AAA must be complied with exactly as written.
On the issue of natural justice, the Court recorded that the parties did not dispute the settled position emerging from the decisions in Sandeep S. Ghandat that members of the managing committee are not entitled to a prior personal hearing before RBI passes an order of supersession under Section 36AAA. Consequently, the challenge on that ground failed.
The Court also agreed with the Single Judge that, although the original supersession order suffered from non-compliance with the statutory consultation requirement, it would not be appropriate to unsettle the administration of the bank after the Administrator had been functioning for a considerable period and numerous actions had already been taken. Equity, public interest, and the interests of depositors weighed against restoring the old management at that stage.
Appearances
For Appellants: Advocates Sumathi Dandapani and Millu Dandapani
For Respondents: Advocates P.N. Mohanan and Arun Chandran, Special GP (Co-Operation)

